Reviewed by Colin Jacobson (December 29, 2025)
As video technology became cheaper and cheaper, this made filmmaking more democratic, as many more aspiring artists could create flicks on a shoestring budget. Into this category falls 2013’s DIY horror effort The Brain Hunter.
In 2009, a series of mysterious deaths occurs in a US Midwestern location. They share one commonality: the victims’ brains went missing.
Years later, this menace appears to return. Dr. Von John (Paul McGillicuddy) comes over from the UK to investigate and solve the mystery.
Boy, that makes it sound like Brain Hunter comes with a coherent plot, doesn’t it? Abandon hope all ye who watch this comically awful movie.
Should I grade a movie with a budget of roughly $87 on a curve? Maybe, as it doesn’t seem fair to expect the same quality of a project like this that we would from a big Hollywood affair.
That said, anyone who wants to buy this Blu-ray doesn’t get to pay on a curve. It lists for $30, just the same as more expensive and polished films.
Even if the Blu-ray sold for $3, though, the prospective buyer would overpay. If anything worthwhile emerges from this unmitigated disaster, I can’t find it.
Okay, we do get to see a few attractive, buxom women. Thus ends the positive portion of this review.
As a movie, absolutely nothing about Hunter works. Virtually all aspects of what we view as competent filmmaking fail to manifest here.
The script becomes a major impediment, as the “story” makes little sense and proceeds in a clumsy and incoherent manner. Hunter jumps from one scenario to another with zero fluidity.
This means a narrative that never builds. Plot elements meander in search of purpose.
The editing doesn’t bring any clarity to matters either. Scenes tend to either run oddly long or end abruptly, and the entire project lacks flow or momentum.
Photography fails to frame matters well. Too often we see only parts of heads because the top of the screen lops off the tops of those noggins.
Across the board, the actors seem terrible. Just by random chance, you’d think at least one or two would boast at least minor competence, but each and every cast member proves wholly unconvincing as they vary from wooden to over the top.
Hunter can’t even spell correctly. On occasion, we see subtitles that intend to identify a “residence”.
Expect the text reads “residents”, and this happens more than once. Yikes.
And we also see a “news broadcast” that spells “bodies” as “bodys”. Even for a super-cheap movie, this lack of quality control surprises me.
I genuinely root for DIY indie flicks like this to succeed. Even with severe budgetary restrictions, a movie can prosper thanks to other attributes.
All of these fail and fail spectacularly. Outside of those hot women I mentioned, literally nothing about this cinematic atrocity succeeds.