Reviewed by Colin Jacobson (November 13, 2023)
When 2008’s Twilight became a big hit, additional adaptations from Stephenie Meyer’s series of novels became inevitable. 2009 brought New Moon while 2010 delivered Eclipse.
2011 introduced the conclusion of the saga – or at least halfway there. As implied by the title, Breaking Dawn - Part 1 gives us only the first part of the finale.
After many ups and downs, human Bella Swan (Kristen Stewart) marries vampire Edward Cullen (Robert Pattinson). This doesn’t go off without controversy, as her werewolf pal Jacob Black (Taylor Lautner) feels distressed to lose Bella.
Nonetheless, the newlyweds head on their honeymoon and Bella becomes pregnant. Given the half-human, half-vampire nature of this baby, complications ensue, both in Bella’s womb and with others concerned about what this unusual offspring might mean.
If you look back at my reviews for the first three movies, you’ll see I liked Twilight more than expected. Though aimed at a young female audience, it came with enough cleverness and energy to entertain a middle-aged dude like me.
Alas, New Moon and Eclipse largely lost those positives. While they occasionally generated some decent action, they focused more on mopey romantic melodrama and failed to connect.
Should viewers expect anything different from Dawn 1? Nope, as it follows the same turgid template of the prior two films.
If anything, Dawn 1 feels even more stuck in place, mainly because it doesn’t come with nearly enough story to fill two hours. The source novel runs more than 750 pages, which implies more than sufficient content to fill two separate films.
The wedding eats up a huge block of time. A smidgen of plot info emerges in those scenes, but not enough to justify their existence as anything other than sop to fans who want to moon over the romance.
This takes us more than one-fourth of the way into the movie, and matters don’t really improve after the newlyweds go on their honeymoon. Bella and Edward finally Do the Deed but otherwise we spend a long span with their dull honeymoon.
We finally learn of Bella’s pregnancy about halfway into the flick. The tale picks up from there, right?
Not really, mainly because it continues to plod. Again, I feel surprised to learn the movie comes from such a long novel, as Dawn 1 stretches so thin.
Due to the hybrid nature of the fetus, Dawn 1 focuses on the threat to Bella’s life. Like the wedding/honeymoon of the first half, this doesn’t feel like enough to sustain a full hour of film, and the movie makes the events drag.
Of course, another element contributes to the utter lack of drama: the film’s title. Because we get Breaking Dawn Part 1, we go into the flick fully aware that we’ll find Part 2.
Could a final chapter without Bella have existed? Yeah, I guess, but such a prospect seemed intensely unlikely.
As a result, we never feel any concern for Bella’s health. Maybe we think the baby won’t make it, but we go into Dawn 1 with the virtual certainty that Bella’s pregnancy won’t kill her.
This means Dawn 1 offers a slow and tedious slog toward the inevitable. It devotes two hours to material that easily could wrap in 30 minutes or so.
Did fans dig all the mopey melodrama and the extended wedding/honeymoon stuff? Perhaps, but those don’t help Dawn 1 as a film.
It ends up as slow and turgid. Maybe Dawn 2 will complete the franchise on a more compelling note, but after three straight bad films, I lack much optimism.
Footnote: a tag scene that teases Dawn 2 appears early in the end credits.