As 2005 ended and 2006 began, everywhere you looked, many folks spouted their opinions about Brokeback Mountain. A polarizing film, liberals adored it and championed it while conservatives chafed at its tale of gay cowboys. It became hard to find neutral parties as the two sides split in a decisive manner.

Along the way, the movie itself got lost, as it became difficult to view Brokeback as a film and not as a social cause. Whether praise for its message of tolerance or condemnation of its alleged assault on family values, few of the discussions seemed to focus on its merits as a piece of cinematic entertainment.

Perhaps that’s because Brokeback just isn’t that scintillating once we separate it from its controversial elements. It provides a twist on the standard love story but lacks the heart to make it truly involving.

Initially set in Wyoming during the summer of 1963, young cowboys Ennis Del Mar (Heath Ledger) and Jack Twist (Jake Gyllenhaal) gain employment on Brokeback Mountain where they guard sheep from coyotes. Stuck in the isolated setting, they eventually bond and their relationship turns sexual as the months pass.

When their time together ends, they go their separate ways and it seems uncertain if their paths will cross again. Both clearly feel a strong tie to each other, though the firmly closeted Ennis tries his best to deny this.

Ennis marries long-time girlfriend Alma (Michelle Williams) and attempts to follow a standard lifestyle. Jack also takes the straight path and ends up wed to sexy rodeo gal Lureen Newsome (Anne Hathaway).

Despite these moves, Ennis and Jack manage to reunite. They get together for occasional “fishing trips”, though they mostly get freaky with each other during those visits. Brokeback follows their surreptitious relationship over the decades and examines how it affects their lives.

Frankly, it’s hard to find any real fault with Brokeback, as it always remains impeccably tasteful and avoids obvious sermonizing. It would be easy for a film like this to pound us over the head with its message, and there can be no doubt that the movie sympathizes with the plight of gays forced to live lives unfaithful to their true selves, but the story never succumbs to easy options.

It must be tempting to make Jack and Ennis into martyrs and/or angels and also to demonize everyone else. Happily, the leads come across as real people with all the usual positives and negatives, and the same goes for most of the supporting roles as well.

Sure, some of the characters are cartoonish - Lureen’s overbearing father seems especially one-dimensional. However, the respective wives don’t turn into the usual shrews or harpies, so we feel real emotion for their situations as well.

I sure can’t criticize the acting of Brokeback. The male leads find the hearts of their characters and don’t offer easy heroics to make us like them.

As for the women, both react in different ways to their distant, uninvolved menfolk, but both Williams and Hathaway present realistic portrayals. They behave the way you’d expect and stay true to the situations.

Add to that its progressive message and gorgeous scenery and Brokeback should be a slam-dunk success, right? Unfortunately, that’s not how I see it.

One subjective problem stemmed from my foreknowledge of the story. I wish I’d initially gone into Brokeback with no awareness of its plot twists, as they made it too easy to see significance where none may really exist.

To be specific, I couldn’t help but be amused by the little character moments that foreshadow the love affair between Ennis and Jack. They exchange plenty of long, lingering glances before they get it on, and the movie seems poised to connect them in this way. I’m not proud of my Beavis and Butthead tendencies, but I must admit I giggled occasionally since I thought the film made it so clear where things would go.

Maybe that’s not the case and I only saw it that way because I already knew what would happen. If I’d taken in Brokeback with no earlier awareness, I may not have seen these scenes in the same way.

With or without this attitude, though, I simply find Brokeback to offer a curiously distancing affair. To me, that becomes its biggest flaw.

The film seems so concerned with its underlying theme and its ultimate message that it forgets to offer an involving story and characters about whom I really care. Despite the best efforts of the actors, I feel for them as symbols but not as people.

In other words, I care about them because I’m supposed to care about them. Sometimes we root for movie characters simply due to conditioning, and that’s what happens here. Nothing about the personalities causes me to develop real feelings for them, but the situations and general issues lead me to want them to prosper.

While I applaud the subtlety and restraint of Brokeback, it ends up as a double-edged sword. The lack of passion leaves the movie with a cold center. That makes the flick one that earns my respect but not one that merits my affection or heart.

Brokeback Mountain appears in an aspect ratio of approximately 1.85:1 on this Blu-ray Disc. Though usually satisfying, the image could be a bit erratic.

Definition seemed inconsistent, though with many more ups than downs. The movie usually offered nice delineation, but some softness crept in at times. I noticed no issues with jagged edges or shimmering, though, and no signs of source flaws or edge haloes occurred

Given its restrained tone, the movie’s palette followed suit. The outdoors settings boasted lush greens and looked good, but much of the rest of the film went with blander hues. In any case, the colors were consistently accurate and decisive. Blacks appeared deep and dark, but shadows could be a little heavy.

Actually, the low-light shots usually seemed fine, but a few images were somewhat dense. The prime culprit came from the scene in which Jack and Ennis first did the deed. I suspected this shot was intentionally shot, but it appeared dimmer than expected – and tougher to discern than I remembered from the theatrical showing I saw. In any case, the visuals of Brokeback didn’t excel but they were more than satisfactory.

To my surprise, the film’s DTS-HD MA 5.1 audio proved pretty expansive. The outdoors shots opened up matters with a nice sense of environment, and the occasional louder element filled out the speakers well. From rodeo sequences to storms to other pieces, the mix broadened nicely and used all five speakers to good effect.

Audio quality always seemed solid. Music was lush and full, while effects came across as accurate and dynamic.

Most of the movie remained restrained, but the occasional louder piece was clean and concise. Speech appeared natural and crisp. This was a solid soundtrack for a character film.

How did the Blu-ray compare to the Collector’s Edition DVD from 2007? Audio showed a little more range and warmth, and visuals looked tighter and better resolved. The Blu-ray offered a decent upgrade over the DVD.

The Blu-ray repeats the CE’s extras, and these start with the 17-minute, 13-second *A Groundbreaking Success. It includes notes from journalist/blogger Matt Zoller Seitz, film critic B. Ruby Rich, writer/producer Diana Ossana, executive producer Michael Costigan, director Ang Lee, Variety editor-in-chief Peter Bart, producer James Schamus, journalist Alonso Duralde, and actors Jake Gyllenhaal, and Heath Ledger.

As implied by the title, “Success” looks at the film’s reception. We get a few notes about why it appealed to those involved but mostly hear about how the public and critics reacted to the flick.

This remains more self-congratulatory than I’d like and never really digs into the factors behind Brokeback’s surprising success. We get general thoughts but not much more than that.

Impressions from the Film lasts two minutes, 33 seconds as it offers a basic still gallery. We see a mix of shots from the movie; no behind the scenes images appear. It’s a waste of time.

In the 11-minute, 17-second Music from the Mountain, we hear from Lee, Schamus, Costigan, composer Gustavo Santaolalla, music supervisor Kathy Nelson, and singers/songwriters Mary McBride, Teddy Thompson, Steve Earle and Rufus Wainwright.

We find out how Santaolalla came onto the project as well as the development of the score, songs and instrumentation choices. Inevitably, it throws out lots of praise for his work, but we get enough decent information about the work to make this a useful program.

On Being a Cowboy runs five minutes, 43 seconds and mixes comments from stunt coordinator Kirk Jarrett, animal wrangler TJ Bews, executive producer/screenwriter Diana Ossana, wrangler Don Gillespie, director Ang Lee and actors Heath Ledger, Jake Gyllenhaal and Anne Hathaway.

The show looks at the actors’ training to play the cowboy parts of the film. This short piece offers a decent examination of how the participants went through “cowboy camp”.

We focus on the director in Directing from the Heart: Ang Lee. The seven-minute, 27-second show includes remarks from Lee, Ledger, Hathaway, Gyllenhaal, Ossana, executive producer Michael Costigan, producer James Schamus, cinematographer Rodrigo Prieto, costume designer Marit Allen, and actors Anna Faris, Randy Quaid, and Linda Cardellini.

The program reflects Lee’s directorial style and his work, why Lee took on the flick, the movie’s cinematography and visual elements, and how the director works with the cast. Occasional nuggets of useful material emerge here, but “Heart” mostly acts as a puff piece to tout Lee’s skills. We don’t get much meat in this fluffy program.

Next we find the 10-minute, 53-second From Script to Screen: Interviews with Larry McMurtry and Diana Ossana. As expected, this presents notes from writers Ossana and McMurtry as well as Schamus, Quaid, Lee, Hathaway. Cardellini, Ledger, Costigan, and Gyllenhaal. The piece looks at Annie Proulx’s original story and its adaptation as well as troubles bringing it to the screen.

We get details about the expansion of the short article into a feature-length film and learn what the writers wanted to accomplish. Though we get a little too much happy talk, they offer nice insight into their work and thought processes in this informative featurette.

For the final featurette, we locate Sharing the Story: The Making of Brokeback Mountain. In this 20-minute, 48-second piece, we get comments from Lee, Ledger, Gyllenhaal, Hathaway, Schamus, Cardellini, Ossana, McMurtry, production designer Judy Becker, composer Gustavo Santaolalla, and actor Michelle Williams.

After a basic recap of story and characters, “Sharing” looks at the short story, its adaptation, and move to the screen, casting, cowboy camp, locations, Lee’s work with the actors and their interactions, animals, shooting the love scenes, and reactions to the movie. Most of the information here already appears in the other featurettes, so don’t expect to learn much.

“Sharing” emphasizes fluff since it exists to promote the film. It’s not very interesting.

Brokeback Mountain inspired passionate debate due to its themes, but the movie itself seemed strangely unaffecting. Though it does everything right on the surface, it never quite connects. The Blu-ray offers reasonably good picture and audio along with some decent extras. I think Brokeback merits a look but I don’t feel it stands as a great film.

To rate this film visit the original review of BROKEBACK MOUNTAIN