DVD Movie Guide @ dvdmg.com
.
Review Archive:  # | A-C | D-F | G-I | J-L | M-O | P-R | S-U | V-Z | Viewer Ratings | Main
COLUMBIA TRISTAR

MOVIE INFO

Director:
James Bridges
Cast:
Jane Fonda, Jack Lemmon, Michael Douglas, Scott Brady, James Hampton, Peter Donat, Wilford Brimley, Richard Herd
Writing Credits:
Mike Gray, T.S. Cook, James Bridges

Tagline:
Today, only a handful of people know what it means ... Soon you will know.

Synopsis:
In this socially conscious thriller, an ambitious female newscaster and her cameraman, a former 1960s radical with a penchant for conspiracy theories, witness and capture on film a potentially disastrous nuclear accident. Joining forces with a concerned engineer at the plant where the near-meltdown occurred, the reporter and the cameraman attempt to expose the subsequent cover-up.

Box Office:
Domestic Gross
$51.718 million.

MPAA:
Rated PG

DVD DETAILS
Presentation:
Widescreen 1.85:1/16x9
Audio:
English Dolby Digital 5.1
English Monaural
French Monaural
Subtitles:
English
French
Japanese
Chinese
Thai
Closed-captioned

Runtime: 122 min.
Price: $19.94
Release Date: 10/26/2004

Bonus:
• “The China Syndrome: A Fusion of Talent” Documentary
• “The China Syndrome: Creating a Controversy” Documentary
• Deleted Scenes
• Filmographies
• Previews


PURCHASE @ AMAZON.COM

EQUIPMENT
Sony 36" WEGA KV-36FS12 Monitor; Sony DA333ES Processor/Receiver; Panasonic CV-50 DVD Player using component outputs; Michael Green Revolution Cinema 6i Speakers (all five); Sony SA-WM40 Subwoofer.

RELATED REVIEWS


The China Syndrome: Special Edition (1979)

Reviewed by Colin Jacobson (October 20, 2004)

It was the kind of free publicity of which a movie studio dreams. The China Syndrome hit screens on March 16, 1979, and the nuclear plant at Three Mile Island experienced a potentially catastrophic situation 12 days later. Real life and fiction heavily intertwined, which naturally sparked audiences to want to see the movie.

That made China a “must-see” back in the spring of 1979, but would it still be interesting 25 years later? Definitely, as it’s barely aged in that span.

At the start of China, we meet Los Angeles TV reporter Kimberly Wells (Jane Fonda). Generally assigned to fluffy human interest stories, she does a remote spot at the Ventana Nuclear Power Plant for a special on energy sources. She works along with cameraman Richard Adams (Michael Douglas), a radical with an anti-nuclear bent.

During their visit, a strange rumbling occurs. At first control room shift supervisor Jack Godell (Jack Lemmon) dismisses it as a routine “turbine trip”, but it looks like something more intense. Richard surreptitiously films the action as Godell narrowly averts a meltdown due to low water levels.

Kimberly and her crew rush back to run the story, but news producer Don Jacovich (Peter Donat) refuses to do so until they find out more about what happened. We see that the owners of Ventana want to open a new plant, so they worry about how this event may affect the upcoming hearings. Jacovich decides to wait until the NRC reports on the Ventana incident before he might run the story. This incenses Richard, who wants the material to air now, so he steals it and eventually shows it to experts to learn more about it.

Back at the plant, Jack looks into the second shudder that occurred after the turbine trip, as he’s not sure what caused it. When she hunts for Richard, Kimberly runs into Jack at a bar, and he attempts to convince her the events were inconsequential, but he clearly doesn’t believe his own propaganda. He gets more and more involved in his own investigation and doesn’t like what he finds. The rest of the movie follows the various parties as they come together to discover the problems and expose the truth.

Most movies with a political bent tend to come across as a product of their era, and that affects China to some degree. Mainly that element manifests itself in the level of deception seen in the film. Though I suppose these topics remain timeless, it’s a very Seventies take on corporate conspiracy and the concern for power/profit over safety. There’s a definite “post-Watergate” vibe to the whole thing.

That said, China lacks the stridency and holier-than-thou attitude I expected from a movie made in 1979. At least until the ending, it maintains a surprisingly calm and objective tone. The film never overtly attacks nuclear power, as it really concerns itself more with abuses of power and the public trust. One will likely take a negative view of nuclear energy away from this movie, but I can’t blame the filmmakers on that, as they don’t try to press that particular agenda on us. The flick lightly defends the general safety of the system but slams the sloppiness and concerns about money over safety.

The conclusion becomes a bit hysterical and illogical, but otherwise, China benefits from a remarkably calm and objective treatment of the subject manner. The absence of a score gives the movie a stark feel that works, and we see action displayed without theatrics. For example, take the staging of the initial incident at the plant. The film depicts this in a simple and concise manner that allows the action to become all the more nerve-wracking.

It certainly helps that China enjoys an excellent cast. During their careers, all three leads earned Oscars for other projects, and both Fonda and Lemmon received nominations for this flick as well. That’s a lot of acting firepower, and each member of the cast delivers the goods. Fonda seems especially good, as she makes sure Kimberly isn’t some sort of super crusader or whatever; Fonda displays the character’s weaknesses and makes her a believable person.

Chalk up The China Syndrome as something of a pleasant surprise. I saw the flick as a kid and liked it but didn’t expect it to hold up well. However, it remains quite a solid piece of work.


The DVD Grades: Picture B+/ Audio B/ Bonus B

The China Syndrome appears in an aspect ratio of approximately 1.85:1 on this single-sided, double-layered DVD; the image has been enhanced for 16X9 televisions. Frankly, I didn’t expect a whole lot from this picture, which meant I felt surprised with the consistently strong visual presentation.

Sharpness always looked great. I never noticed any signs of softness. Instead, the movie consistently remained taut and well-defined. Jagged edges and shimmering created no concerns, and only minimal edge enhancement appeared. Despite the movie’s age, print flaws were minor. I saw occasional bits of grit or specks, but these didn’t crop of frequently, and they caused few distractions.

Given the movie’s stark subject matter, I expected a dull palette. Instead, I found a nicely natural and broad set of colors. The tones came across well, with hues that always appeared rich and dynamic. It wasn’t a colorful extravaganza, but the movie replicated the realistic tones nicely. Blacks also were deep and firm, and except for a couple of shots at the end, shadows looked smooth and appropriately delineated. This one nearly made it to “A” level, as China displayed a very satisfying image.

The pleasant surprises continued with the Dolby Digital 5.1 soundtrack of The China Syndrome. I anticipated a “broad mono” track, but instead I got a mix that opened things up quite well much of the time. Granted, since much of the action displayed limited scope, a lot of the flick did come across as little more than monaural. However, it spread out the material well when necessary. The movie often conveyed a good sense of environment, and the scenes in the nuclear plant gave us a good feel for the machinery. The occasional bits of music also demonstrated nice stereo imaging in the front, though these remained very infrequent.

The best parts came from the livelier scenes. Parts with nuclear accidents kicked into high gear and used the surrounds to make the events engulf us in a convincing manner. A car chase also presented vivid audio and even tossed in some split-surround material. The soundfield occasionally was a little awkward and “speaker specific”, but it remained quite ambitious given its age.

Audio quality sometimes suffered from deficits we would associate with an older movie, but I found little about which I could complain. Speech tended to be a little stiff and reedy but lacked edginess and remained totally intelligible. As I noted, music played a very small role in the proceedings, but when they occurred, the bits were clear and reasonably bright. Effects came across as accurate and dynamic. The louder moments demonstrated good bass response and packed a moderate wallop. Overall, I liked this soundtrack and thought it was above average for its age.

No audio commentary accompanies this special edition of The China Syndrome, but we do find some new documentaries. The China Syndrome: A Fusion of Talent runs for 27 minutes and 33 seconds as it includes movie clips, archival materials, and new interviews. We hear from producer/actor Michael Douglas, executive producer Bruce Gilbert, director James Bridges’ partner Jack Larson, and actors Jane Fonda, James Karen and Peter Donat. They cover how Douglas became a producer and how he latched onto China, the film’s development and casting, a competing project created with Fonda and how the pair came together, finding a director and the growth of the story, the approach to the subject matter and its social context, character issues, thoughts on Jack Lemmon, and general memories and impressions of the film. Very little fluff occurs in this tight program. It succinctly goes over appropriate subjects and proves quite informative and entertaining.

Next we locate The China Syndrome: Creating a Controversy. This 29-minute and 31-second program works the same as “Fusion” and includes statements from Douglas, Gilbert, Fonda, Larson, Karen, and Donat. Essentially, “Controversy” acts as “Part 2” of a piece along with “Fusion”. The participants go into pressures to clean up the look of Douglas’ character, controversies about the subject matter and the way these affected the production, the approach to TV news, production design and sets, cinematography and technical concerns, approaches to the characters and interactions among the performers, issues connected to the social concerns, rough cuts of the movie and the decision to drop most of the music, deleted scenes and Jack Lemmon’s negative reaction to them, problems with the title, controversies that greeted the film’s release and the impact of Three Mile Island. All the same strengths from “Fusion” occur here as well. The program looks into some nuts and bolts issues along with a view of the social topics. It delves into these tightly and works well. We even get to see a funny outtake of Fonda as she hobbles along on a broken foot caused by her enormous shoes.

Three Deleted Scenes appear. These last a total of three minutes, 51 seconds, and come with the titles “Jack and Ted at Harmon’s Place”, “Jack and Ted at the Plant”, and “Kimberly Wells at the Party”. The first two are minor additions that further indicate Jack’s growing safety concerns; they don’t add anything, though “Plant” is amusing just because the looped dialogue sounds shockingly bad. “Party” is moderately entertaining as it shows what a jerk the news anchor is, but it doesn’t do anything to further the story.

Filmographies appear for director James Bridges plus actors Jane Fonda, Jack Lemmon, and Michael Douglas. Finally, we find Previews for The Fog of War, Fail Safe and Secret Window.

Because I’d not seen The China Syndrome since 1979, I feared it’d offer a dated experience. A little of that tone came through, but overall, the movie presented a surprisingly timeless piece. It enjoyed a low-key attitude that made it more effective, and an excellent cast helped bolster it as well. The DVD gives us very good picture and audio plus a roster of extras highlighted by some well-executed documentaries. A solid thriller with social implications, I recommend The China Syndrome.

Viewer Film Ratings: 4.5 Stars Number of Votes: 8
55:
24:
1 3:
02:
01:
View Averages for all rated titles.