Reviewed by Colin Jacobson (Novmber 19, 2026)
We're used to so-called "nepobabies" in Hollywood, but nepograndbabies? Thanks to Grandpa Jack, Duke Nicholson joins that club and he acts as the lead in 2026's The Deputy.
In a small southern town, someone pumps nine bullets into Luke Jordan (Zeb Higgs). Police Chief Franklin Krueger (William H. Macy) instructs part-time Deputy Toby Sawyer (Nicholson) a simple task: to stand guard by the corpse until the coroner can arrive.
Basically a screw-up, Toby screws up, leaves the body unattended and it disappears. Desperate to cover his mistake, Toby searches for Luke’s remains and uncovers a mess of corruption along the way.
Despite what my intro implies, Duke Nicholson doesn’t become the first grandchild of a famous person to appear in Hollywood. Far from it, really, and I can even think of a nepogreatgrandchild thanks to Jack Huston, great-grandson of Walter Huston.
Even though the snarkiness of my opening hints otherwise, I don’t automatically view nepobabies in an unfavorably manner. After all, Jack’s grandpa John, his aunt Anjelica and his uncle Danny all qualify as nepobabies too.
Just because someone comes from an acting lineage doesn’t make them unqualified. The question becomes whether or not Duke shows abilities that make him noteworthy beyond his heritage.
Maybe? While I don’t think Nicholson does poorly, I also don’t sense a great talent here.
Though my synopsis makes Deputy sound wholly serious, it actually delivers a somewhat Coen-esque vibe. This means Toby’s loser side gets played for humor to some degree, mainly as we see the way life continually craps on him.
However, Deputy doesn’t really handle the shifts from quirky comedy to more serious material well. It feels like director Matt Sukkar needs to commit one way or the other because he can’t pull off the variations in a satisfying manner.
When we get Dumbass Toby, Nicholson does pretty well. He gives Toby the right Southern Dirtbag tone and manages reasonable flair.
I don’t think Nicholson takes care of the role’s more dramatic elements, though. He doesn’t come across as an especially deep actor and he can’t find the humanity in the part.
The longer the film goes, the more I wish Sukkar fully went for the comedy. The way it careens from serious scenes to lighter scenes just doesn’t work.
It seems like Sukkar really wants to create a spoof of this sort of story. We expect Toby to rise to the moment and handle the increasing threats, and Sukkar has fun with this.
For instance, when a convenience store clerk tells Toby he doesn’t look like a cop, he replies somberly “I’m the deputy!” and the score delivers an action film sting. This signals the kind of snarky parody tone the movie sporadically indulges.
But not enough to click. I like aspects of Deputy and think it does enough to keep us with it, but the filmmakers’ inability to pull off its tonal shifts makes it erratic.