Reviewed by Colin Jacobson (November 15, 2026)
Plenty of us recall the childhood thrill that occurred when the Good Humor - or other frozen treat brand - truck rolled through the neighborhood. 2026's Ice Cream Man focuses on this concept in a darker manner.
In small-town Bayleen Bay, an Ice Cream Man (Ari Millen) uses his treats to literally entrance the local kids. This leads to violent results.
Except for young Jared Mayfair (Charlie Zeltzer), as the boy avoids the frozen desserts due to a lactose intolerance. As the body count rises, Jared joins with unaffected classmates Tommy (Shiloh O'Reilly) and Mia (Kiori Mirza Waldman) to try to stop the nefarious Ice Cream Man.
For a well-known director, Eli Roth doesn’t seem to enjoy a lot of commercial success. Thanks to a low budget of under $5 million, 2005’s Hostel remains Roth’s most profitable flick, though its worldwide take of $82 million doesn’t seem especially noteworthy.
In terms of raw gross, 2018’s The House With a Clock in Its Walls - a rare foray into family fare from the resolutely “R”-rated Roth – took in the most bucks. Again, however, $132 million didn’t exactly knock off any socks.
With a budget of roughly $115 million, 2024’s Borderlands gave Roth far more money than he’d ever enjoyed – and turned into a massive flop. The movie earned a mere $33 million so it lost buckets of cash.
I suspect this failure prompted Roth to return to the much less expensive world of horror, a genre in which films often cost so little that they can turn profits even with modest grosses. However, even with a tiny $5.5 million budget, Ice Cream Man didn’t get into the black, as it wound up with $8.5 million.
Which gets me back to my surprise that a “name” director with nearly 25 years experience can’t find much of an audience. The question now becomes whether or not Ice Cream Man deserved a better economic fate.
Not really. Though I think Ice Cream Man shows glimmers that make it better than its weak reviews imply, it nonetheless fails to come together as a satisfying project.
Ice Cream Man does start in a promising manner. It opens in an intriguing way with some echoes of 2025’s hit Weapons as we watch children behave in odd ways.
However, Roth quickly shifts from an unsettling creepy vibe to graphic horror. Once the violence starts, Roth indulges in oodles of gore.
Honestly, Roth feels much more interested in the blood and guts than he does in an actual story. Much of the time, Ice Cream Man feels like loosely connected nasty shenanigans that Roth hopes will suffice as entertainment.
Tim Burton took a similar approach to 1996’s Mars Attacks!, a flick in which much of the fun revolved around nutty alien antics. However, Roth lacks the charm and creativity of Burton, so his stabs at kooky mayhem flop.
Basically a zombie film in disguise, Roth tips his hat to buckets of other movies. He even directly lifts a scene from 1963’s The Birds.
Elements like that mean Ice Cream Man can feel like a horror parody, and Roth does embrace a fair amount of comedy. Unfortunately, most of the humor doesn’t connect.
Roth tends to remind me of Seth MacFarlane. Both seem intelligent and can produce clever material but both also tend too often to opt for lowest common denominator fare.
Roth’s unwillingness to really challenge himself becomes the biggest obstacle to success for Ice Cream Man. Despite some good elements, too much of the movie indulges cheap gore without real tension or scares.
Footnote: a comedic tag appears after the conclusion of the end credits.