Reviewed by Colin Jacobson (November 6, 2025)
Generally a genre that benefits from a sense of claustrophobia, the super-widescreen CinemaScope process doesn’t sound like a great fit for a film noir effort. Nonetheless, 1955’s I Died a Thousand Times used its 2.55:1 dimensions, for better or for worse.
After eight years in prison, Roy Earle (Jack Palance) gets his release. While he wants to retire, his former mob boss “Big Man” (Lon Chaney Jr.) pushes Roy to conduct one last heist.
This sends Roy and a team of misfits to a mountain resort. They plan a major robbery but they encounter a series of snags.
As I mentioned at the start, a noir-leaning tale like Died seems like an awkward fit for the 2.55:1 CinemaScope frame. Warner clearly wanted to push the format as heavily as possible, though, so I guess they figured it didn’t matter if the subject suited the photography.
I admit that this nagged at me as I watched Died. The cinematography strongly left the impression of a broad epic and it felt too expansive for a tale with the more intimate range seen here.
Not that this harpooned Died, though. Even if the framing felt wrong for the story at hand, the movie still becomes a reasonably engaging crime flick.
Albeit one without a lot of creativity. “Criminal Who Wants Out But Finds Himself Drawn Back In” goes back ages, and Died doesn’t find anything especially fresh to do with the theme.
Still, with a good script from WR Burnett and more than competent direction from Stuart Heisler, the movie progresses at a good pace and offers reasonable drama. We get a solid cast as well.
Along with Palance and Chaney, we find Shelley Winters, Lee Marvin, and Earl Holliman among others. We even see Dennis Hopper in a tiny role.
Palance does well as our lead, especially given the manner in which the script pushes his emotional range. While we expect him to pull off the hard-bitten tough guy, Palance also manages a softer side.
Parts of Died revolve around a semi-sorta love triangle among Roy, beautiful young physically-impaired small-town girl Velma Goodhue (Lori Nelson) and gangster gal Marie Garson (Winters). This follows some surprising paths, especially as they accentuate Roy’s emotions.
Though these threads potentially seem sappy, Palance plays them with such honesty that they work. He lacked the right look for a leading man but he showed convincing dimensionality in this role.
All of this comes together for a fairly strong mix of crime tale and melodrama. Died takes us on a reasonably compelling journey.