K-19: The Widowmaker appears in an aspect ratio of approximately 2.35:1 on this Blu-ray Disc. This was a decent but not great image.
Sharpness was a bit iffy at times. Though most of the movie exhibited fairly good delineation, occasional soft shots appeared. These became exacerbated by some signs of edge haloes. Jagged edges and moiré effects created no concerns, and with a natural layer of grain, I didn’t suspect heavy-handed digital noise reduction. The movie also lacked any print flaws.
A dark film, K-19 featured a low-key and restricted palette. Really, the only example of vivid colors I recall came from a scene in which one of the sailors saw his girlfriend on his way to the sub. Red and blue lighting also played an important part at times, and the disc kept them tight and distinct. Otherwise, the film stayed almost monochromatic most of the time.
Black levels seemed nicely deep and dense, while shadow detail looked clean and accurate. With so many low-light sequences, those needed to appear clear and visible, and that occurred. The transfer was good enough for a “B-“.
I encountered no such problems with the Dolby TrueHD 5.1 soundtrack of K-19, as it provided a vibrant and involving piece of work at all times. The soundfield spread through all five channels nicely, as it created a clean and encompassing sense of environment. The segments on the sub came to life well, as they included realistic effects that matched the setting; the pressure the audio demonstrated during the very deep dive piece seemed nearly unbearable.
Of course, the film’s louder sequences all kicked into action neatly. For example, when the sub broke through the ice, it did so with a bold sonic impact. The soundfield used all five speakers appropriately and logically.
Audio quality also came across as positive. Speech seemed natural and warm, with no issues related to intelligibility or edginess. Music appeared bright and dynamic. The score seemed distinct and lively at all times.
Effects sounded clean and accurate, and they packed a nice punch when necessary. Bass response came across as deep and tight throughout the film. Ultimately, the audio of K-19 helped complement the action.
How did this Blu-ray compare to the 2002 DVD? Audio seemed broader and fuller, while visuals demonstrated superior definition, cleanliness and clarity. Even though I wasn’t wild about the transfer, it offered an upgrade over the DVD.
The Blu-ray repeats the extras from the DVD. We start with an audio commentary from director Kathryn Bigelow and director of photography Jeff Cronenweth, both of whom sit together for this running, screen-specific piece. The technical emphasis of the track makes it a little dry at times, but the pair prove to be reasonably engaging most of the time.
They discuss the challenges they experienced via their dealings in Russia as well as many issues related to the nuts and bolts of the filmmaking process. At times, they indulge in too much praise of the other participants, but generally K-19 features a fairly interesting and informative commentary.
After this we locate a series of video programs. The Making of K-19: The Widowmaker runs 20 minutes, 16 seconds and features remarks from director Bigelow, actors Liam Neeson, Harrison Ford, Peter Sarsgaard, Steve Nicolson, Christian Camargo, Arsenty Sydelnykov, producers Christine Whitaker, Edward S. Feldman, and Joni Sighvatsson, writer Christopher Kyle, marine coordinator Lance H. Julian, assistant marine coordinator Harry L. Julian, production designer Michael Novotny, and art director Arvinder Grewal. “Making” tells us the plot as well as notes about the cast, the Russian locations, information related to the recreation of the sub, and the attention to detail for the film. Though still promotional in nature, “Making” includes a fair amount of good information, and it provides a superficial but generally entertaining look at the production.
Next we find a featurette entitled Exploring the Craft: Make-Up Techniques. It lasts five minutes, 27 seconds and covers two topics: radiation effects and old-age makeup. We hear from Harrison Ford, special effects make-up artist Gordon Smith and make-up artist Michael Laudata. For the most part, we listen to the make-up guys chat about the work while we watch them do it. I don’t recommend you examine the radiation piece while you eat – I made that mistake – but this piece seems tight and informative.
For notes about some of the visual effects, we can check out Breaching the Hull, a five-minute and 11-second featurette. It covers the creation of the scene in which the K-19 busts through the ice, and it shows lots of good material from the miniature shoot. We also hear comments from visual effects supervisor Steven Rosenbaum and miniatures director of photography Peter Field. The show demonstrates the methods used for this kind of material nicely, and the program delves into its specific topic well.
In addition to the film’s theatrical trailer, the disc finishes with It’s in the Details. This featurette fills 11 minutes and 50 seconds as it looks at the filmmakers’ emphasis on reality. We hear from Kathryn Bigelow, Harrison Ford, actors Peter Sarsgaard and Peter Sebbings, director of photography Jeff Cronenweth, property master Deryck Blake, production designer Karl Juliusson, technical advisor Captain Sergei Aprelev, art director Arvinder Grewal, and producer Joni Sighvatsson. They discuss the research that went into the film plus how they built the sets based on the original specs, a visit to the actual K-19, “physicalized” rehearsals, the training through which the actors went, and a few other elements. At times this program feels a little self-aggrandizing, but it still aptly illustrates all the work that went into the film, and it adds some valuable material.
Though audiences mostly ignored it, K-19: The Widowmaker offers a fairly entertaining and provocative piece of work. It gives us a tense and edgy tale that involves a near-disaster from the past and generally covers this material in a vivid and engrossing manner. The Blu-ray provides erratic but mostly good picture along with excellent audio and a selection of useful bonus materials. This becomes a mostly satisfying release for an enjoyable movie.
To rate this film visit the original review of K-19