Reviewed by Colin Jacobson (November 18, 2023)
With 2023’s Oppenheimer, Christopher Nolan enjoyed spectacular success. Not only did this three-hour historical drama gross a remarkable $976 million worldwide, but also it snared both Best Director and Best Picture Academy Awards for the filmmaker.
For his follow-up, Nolan adapted Homer’s ancient Greek text and experienced even greater financial success, as 2026’s The Odyssey took in a stunning $1.8 billion total. Time will tell if Nolan gets more Oscar love for Odyssey but at the very least, this establishes that Nolan can sell tickets for subjects that wouldn’t do nearly as well from any other director.
Set in olden days, King Odysseus (Matt Damon) of Ithaca left 20 years earlier to participate in the Trojan Wars. Ever since, his wife Queen Penelope (Anne Hathaway) and now-adult son Telemachus (Tom Holland) have waited patiently despite the presence of those who would challenge for the throne.
Across all those years, Odysseus leads an every-dwindling crew back to Ithaca, as they deal with a myriad of challenges. Odysseus refuses to quit and battles his way to get home.
That synopsis implies a more chronological framework than Odyssey takes. Across more than two decades of action, it jumps from one time period to another, mainly to alternate between “present day” and the experiences of Odysseus in the prior 20 years.
I get why Nolan uses this structure but I feel less sure that it works. In particular, Odyssey drags when it spends time with Penelope, Telemachus and the rest.
Again, I understand the dramatic necessity for this material. If Nolan wants us to invest in everything Odysseus goes through to return home, we need reminders of what he left behind.
Nonetheless, I can’t say that I ever really took much interest in Penelope, Telemachus or the others. While they play an important role in the proceedings, Odyssey doesn’t make them especially compelling.
Honestly, the first hour of Odyssey can become somewhat slow going. Some of that stems from a moderate focus on Penelope etc. but even without that, it simply feels like the movie needs a while to get into gear.
Actually, I must admit two other factors influenced my less than enthralled perspective during that opening hour. One simply comes with the intensely high expectations that every new Nolan film creates.
Nolan’s flicks now occupy “event” status and we foresee greatness in each one. With that as backdrop, it can become tough to live up to what we anticipate.
Also, early in the film, Odyssey includes a scene of extreme animal cruelty that shocked me when I saw the film theatrically. The sequence comes out of nowhere and upset me so much that it took me probably half an hour to get past it.
As the saying goes, no animals got harmed in the making of the movie. Nonetheless, the segment threw me off badly and did the same for others, as I heard more than a few people also troubled by this part of the film.
Frankly, I don’t know why Nolan included it – at least not as I write. I’ve yet to watch this set’s supplements so perhaps the director justifies the scene there.
All I know for certain is that the sequence made it tough for me to connect with Odyssey for a chunk of time and it also ensured I hated the character who perpetrated the cruelty the entire rest of the way. Though Odyssey paints him as a hero, I could never accept him as anything other than a monster.
After this off-putting moment, Nolan doubles down on his desire to alienate animal lovers a few minutes later. The “suitors” who hope to gain the crown and wed Penelope toss Odysseus’s faithful aging dog Argos onto a literal dung heap to die.
This scene comes with a bit more dramatic purpose than the earlier one, mainly because it contributes to the audience’s negative view of the “suitors”. However, as someone who currently cares for an elderly pooch, it hit too close to home, especially given that it comes so soon after the other upsetting scene.
My second screening of Odyssey allowed me to feel less bothered by these segments, though I admit I blocked the screen during the more troubling one. I just didn’t need to see that again.
Even if I didn’t do that, the scene wouldn’t have set me off like it did summer 2026 just because I knew it would come. Part of the issue theatrically stemmed from the fact the sequence sprung up out of nowhere so I couldn’t emotionally prepare for it.
Anyway, I continue to feel that even an Odyssey without these segments would still drag somewhat during its first hour. Again, much of this occurs due to the less than compelling elements related to Penelope and “modern day” material.
The film returns to this era of Ithaca along the way. It also eventually brings the dueling stories full circle by the end.
As noted, though, Odyssey simply fares best when it sticks with Odysseus and leaves Ithaca-based moments to a minimum. Again, while I note the dramatic necessity of these, they just don’t deliver a lot of engagement.
At least the Odysseus-based narrative compensates. Episodic in nature, his journey takes him on a variety of escapades that provide real action and drama.
These also manage to allow character development, as we see how Odysseus obsesses over his journey. I don’t know if Nolan digs into this in the deepest manner, however.
Odysseus clearly offers a flawed hero, as he seems so obsessed with his return to Ithaca that he risks the lives of others. Granted, they want to get home as well, but Odysseus’s monomaniacal focus means he ignores the dangers too much.
A deeper film would better explore these issues, whereas they remain fairly superficial here. Not that Nolan ignores them, but the notion that Odysseus’s desire to reunite with his family trumps all else makes his choices seem less fateful.
I don’t want to make it sound like Odyssey lacks character depth, as it delves relatively deeply given its essential residence in the action film genre. It does better in this regard than most we find under that banner.
But again, the Nolan name elevates expectations of Greatness! and that means anything less can disappoint. I admit this seems like an unfair bar to set but Chris can’t blame anyone other than himself for making so many strong movies over the last 25 years or so since Memento made him a cinematic rising star.
Whatever “issues” I might find, Nolan does largely keep our attention across nearly three hours of Odyssey, which seems like no mean feat. The man also clearly knows how to stage an action scene.
The latter factor allows Odyssey to pack a strong punch. Though the tale’s ancient Greek origins might imply something different to modern viewers, the film really does exist under the “action flick” banner and Nolan makes sure to deliver the goods in that regard.
All of this leaves Odyssey as mid-tier for Nolan but very good for almost anyone else. Even without the animal cruelty, it wouldn’t become one of my favorites but the film generates enough drama and thrills to succeed.