DVD Movie Guide @ dvdmg.com
Review Archive:  # | A-C | D-F | G-I | J-L | M-O | P-R | S-U | V-Z | Viewer Ratings | Main


Pearl Jam

Rated NR

Widescreen 1.78:1/16x9
English Dolby Digital 5.1
English PCM Stereo
Not Closed-captioned

Runtime: 170 min.
Price: $19.98
Release Date: 11/11/2003

• “Throw Your Arms Around Me”
• “Dead Man”
• “Bu$hleaguer”
• “Fortunate Son”
• “Down”
• “All Those Yesterdays”
• Matt Cam
• Easter Egg

Search Titles:

Sony 36" WEGA KV-36FS12 Monitor; Sony DA333ES Processor/Receiver; Panasonic CV-50 DVD Player using component outputs; Michael Green Revolution Cinema 6i Speakers (all five); Sony SA-WM40 Subwoofer.


[an error occurred while processing this directive]

Pearl Jam: Live At The Garden (2003)

Reviewed by Colin Jacobson (January 20, 2004)

For one of the best bargains in rock, look no further than Pearl Jam’s 10 Club. For a measly $15 a year, fans can join and get priority access to tickets for PJ concerts. Memberships also gets us sporadically-mailed newsletter and an annual Christmas single, but those aren’t the reason I belong – it’s all about the tickets, baby!

10 Club membership was a good deal for the first three PJ tours I attended, even though we were allowed to purchase one pair of tickets for one show. Since these seats were always good and the process required little fuss, it was worth the minor membership expenditure.

However, for the band’s 2003 tour, membership really began to present its privileges. For that trek, 10 Clubbers could buy a pair of tickets to any and all of the originally announced concerts. (Added-on performances like a second night in Philadelphia fell outside of this window.)

This encouraged other fans and me to take in multiple nights. Seating was based on seniority in the club; those who’d been with the 10 Club the longest got the best seats. I’ve been with them since 1994, which gives me a pretty low – and good – number; it doesn’t guarantee me great seats, but it ensures very good ones.

With that in mind, I attended seven shows on the 2003 tour. That’s not many for me when compared to the 20 times I saw Springsteen in 2003 – along with 11 Bruce concerts in 2002 – but since I’d only seen PJ three times total prior to that year, it marked a big leap.

And it paid off nicely, thanks to the 10 Club. I usually ended up in the first four rows and never sat farther back than the 10th row. That occurred for the July 9th show at Madison Square Garden, a performance that saw an enormous 10 Club presence; originally it was announced as the last concert of the tour, which added to the natural demand one finds in New York. (PJ eventually did another half-dozen or so shows after that one; the tour finally finished a couple of weeks later in Mexico City.)

Fans also thought the July 9th show – the second of two at MSG – would be a real barnburner. As it happened, the concert was good but not the better of the pair. It turns out the prior night presented the real winner, a more than two and a half hour extravaganza that showed PJ at the height of their powers.

And that’s the one we find on this new DVD logically entitled Pearl Jam: Live at the Garden. The 30-song setlist mixes old and new and famous and obscure to create a lively show. From 2002’s Riot Act, we find eight songs: “Love Boat Captain”, “Save You”, “Green Disease”, “Cropduster”, “I Am Mine”, “You Are”, “1/2 Full”, and “Thumbing My Way”. 2000’s Binaural produces only “Grievance”, while 1998’s Yield offers “Wishlist”, “Low Light”, “Faithfull” and “Do the Evolution”.

As we head to 1996’s No Code, we get “In My Tree” and “Lukin”. 1994’s Vitalogy presents “Last Exit”, “Spin the Black Circle”, and “Better Man”. Off of 1993’s Vs we find “Rearviewmirror”, “Indifference” and “Daughter”, while 1991’s Ten features “Even Flow” and “Black”.

The rest of the material comes from various odds and ends. “Gimme Some Truth” covers the 1971 John Lennon song, though Eddie alters it slightly to mention George W. Bush. PJ also cover the Who via 1971’s “Baba O’Riley”. As far as I can tell, PJ never did their own studio renditions of those numbers.

However, they did record a studio take of another cover, the Dead Boys’ “Sonic Reducer”, which first appeared on the 1992 Christmas single. The 2000 Christmas single produced “Crown of Thorns”, which covered a track by Mother Love Bone, the precursor to Pearl Jam. “Breath” comes from the soundtrack to the movie Singles, while “Crazy Mary” originally showed up on a benefit album called Sweet Relief. Finally, concert staple “Yellow Ledbetter” initially saw life as the B-side to the “Jeremy” single.

That creates a nice mix of material, virtually all of which receives solid performances. PJ can be pretty sloppy live at times, a factor that actually makes them somewhat more endearing at times. They generally seem pretty tight here, though, and they offer good renditions of the various tunes. Frankly, I could live without the never-ending versions of tracks like “Daughter” or “Rearviewmirror”, though they seem less plodding at home than at the arena. They tend to really drag the show in the actual venue, whereas I guess the distractions and comfort level of my home theater help make them more palatable.

Overall, spirits and emotions seem high. Actually, all seven of the shows I saw in 2003 offered PJ in good form, which is why this one never stood out to me that much. Yeah, it was the best of the punch, but not by an enormous margin. All of the concerts seemed vibrant and energetic. MSG just notched those factors up a little and displayed the band with a little more commitment than normal.

Granted, those of us in the crowd helped! As Eddie alludes, at one point during the encores, the floor started to seriously bounce, which isn’t a normal occurrence at MSG. I remember this, and it freaked me out at the time. But no one got hurt, the building survived, and it remains a cool moment.

Pearl Jam’s only prior concert DVD went the compilation route. It presented songs from a mix of shows and didn’t feature more than one or two from any particular performance. That worked fine, but I’m happy they decided to document one specific show for Garden. The compilation format might mean that we get the very best versions of the various songs, but I prefer the coherence and immediacy of a DVD that features one entire concert, presented in its natural order.

As with Touring Band 2000, one could call Garden an amateur effort. Those in the PJ organization shot it on consumer grade DV cameras. (2000 was filmed in a similar way, though they used superior quality equipment this time.)

However, it would be a mistake to confuse “amateur effort” for “amateurish”. Indeed, Garden seemed better shot and executed than many professional efforts. The camerawork was calm and focused on appropriate elements of the show. We got no self-consciously funky angles, as the photographers stayed with the main action.

The editing also seemed remarkably restrained compared to most modern efforts. You find no obnoxious quick cutting or silly effects to mar the presentation. Instead, Garden accurately and concisely captured the performance at hand. Even the disc break comes at a good spot. The first DVD ends at the conclusion of the main set, while the second platter includes all the encores.

I doubt that anything in Live at the Garden will change the mind of a Pearl Jam hater, but fans will clearly eat up this solid show. The evening found the band in good form as they plowed through many different facets of their large back catalog. It’s a strong presentation of a fine concert.

The DVD Grades: Picture B-/ Audio B+/ Bonus C

Pearl Jam: Live at the Garden appears in an aspect ratio of 1.78:1 on these single-sided, double-layered DVDs; the image has been enhanced for 16X9 televisions. That surprised me, but don’t expect professional-level picture quality from Garden; it definitely looked much better than Touring Band 2000, but no one will confuse it with Springsteen’s Live In New York City, another program shot at MSG.

Sharpness mostly looked good, though those elements varied. A mix of shots came across as somewhat ill defined and fuzzy, but those stayed reasonably minor. The show only sporadically achieved great clarity, but the images usually seemed fairly detailed and accurate. Occasional examples of jagged edges appeared, but I saw no instances of shimmering or edge enhancement. Some light video artifacts emanated from the source material, but no other issues interfered with the image.

As with most concert presentations, colors stemmed mainly from the lighting, and those elements seemed erratic. Much of the time the hues appeared fairly firm and distinctive, but variations occurred. At times the tones looked somewhat thick and overly dense. Black levels usually seemed acceptably rich and dark, but they also occasionally took on moderate bluish tones. Shadow detail was decent but unexceptional. Lots of low-light shots occurred, and most of them seemed fairly visible, but things could get a bit dim at times. Overall, Garden looked good enough to merit a “B-“, and it certainly exceeded my expectations for a Pearl Jam DVD.

While not one of the best mixes I’ve heard, the Dolby Digital 5.1 audio of Garden seemed consistently satisfying. The sound field remained pretty heavily anchored toward the front spectrum, but that seemed appropriate for the presentation. Vocals were well placed in the center, while instrumentation spread cleanly and accurately across the forward channels. As one might hope, the dual guitars split to each side of the spectrum, which makes perfect sense. The rears mainly added a little musical atmosphere as well as crowd noise. This supported the front logical and naturally. Some split-surround work appeared at times – guitars skittered across the rear during part of “Rearviewmirror” – but those occasions occurred only rarely.

Audio quality sounded generally solid. Eddie’s vocals suffered from a little too much “arena reverb” but generally came across as distinctive and firm. I noticed no issues connected to edginess from the singing. Guitars displayed fine clarity and precision, while bass received good support and depth. Larry’s drumming was clean and distinct and showed none of the “boxiness” that often affects concert percussion. Bass response occasionally sounded a little thin, but most of the time the track presented solid depth and warmth. Overall, this was a vivid and robust presentation that documented the music well.

Most of the set’s extras appear on DVD Two, and these offer a mix of additional performances. We open with “Throw Your Arms Around Me”, played in Australia along with Mark Seymour, the track’s composer. Next we get “Dead Man” played solo by Eddie. He often would come out before the opening act and do one quick number as a thanks to the fans who arrived early.

After this we discover the band’s most infamous song, “Bu$hleaguer”. We get a montage treatment here that includes bits from a number of performances. It seems unclear if the controversial Denver rendition is among them, though.

“Fortunate Son” also receives the montage treatment. The rendition comes from one performance, but we see images of the many guests who accompanied PJ on the tune throughout the tour. Actually, not all the performers did “Son”, as some other tunes clearly entered the visual mix; for example, we see the same snippets of Ben Harper that came from the MSG show.

For “Down”, we get the studio version of the track. This accompanies another montage of images; some come from backstage, while others are from shows. We even start with shots of Mike as he tosses out the first pitch at a minor league baseball game. Lastly, we hear “All Those Yesterdays”, and it displays a montage connected to the road crew who help stage the show. Overall, the added songs are a nice touch, though the montage format gets a little old.

A feature also found on the Touring Band 2000 DVD, the Matt Cam presents an alternate angle option. We can watch a few songs with the camera focused solely on drummer Matt Cameron. These include “Last Exit”, “Green Disease”, “Cropduster”, “You Are” and “Crown of Thorns”. Obviously it’s a limited piece, and since it only covers one member of the band, it’s not as cool as the “Select-a-Stone” feature on the Stones’ Four Flicks. Still, it remains fun to check out the songs in this way.

One additional number appears as an Easter egg, which appears on DVD One. For a Mexico City performance of Temple of the Dog’s “Hunger Strike”, access Title 2 on the disc. Then you can watch the live song. It’s a good addition, so I have no idea why it got hidden.

Given their apparent aversion to the form, I didn’t think we’d ever get a well-shot DVD of a complete Pearl Jam concert. I was wrong, as Live at the Garden indeed presents a full show and in fairly good form. The performance finds the band at the top of their game, and the discs display the concert cleanly and efficiently. Picture quality seemed erratic but generally good, and audio sounded clear and distinctive. In addition, we find a few decent extras. Not only will fans clearly adore Garden, but also it seems like a great place for newbies to start.

Viewer Film Ratings: 4.6666 Stars Number of Votes: 39
1 3:
View Averages for all rated titles.