Back in 2003, Pirates of the Caribbean: The Curse of the Black Pearl shocked almost everyone. Most expected it to suck, but it actually provided a fresh, delightful little adventure.

Moviegoers agreed and the film raked in a very solid $305 million in the US. That was good enough for third place at the box office that year, behind only Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King and Finding Nemo.

Because of Pearl’s success, observers anticipated much from its first sequel, 2006’s Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Man’s Chest. Even so, the flick surpassed expectations.

Not only did it live up to the first movie’s earnings, but also it kept on going, as Chest pulled in a then-remarkable $422 million. Chest ended up as the year’s financial champion, and by a wide margin, as it outgrossed second place contender Night at the Museum by $173 million.

While Chest outdid the first movie’s monetary success, the filmmakers found it more difficult to replicate the original’s sense of fun and adventure. It tried, though, as it brought back virtually all the notable characters from Pearl.

Set about a year after the events in the first movie, Chest shows heroes Will Turner (Orlando Bloom) and Elizabeth Swann (Keira Knightley) as authorities plan to hang them for their role in the escape of pirate Captain Jack Sparrow (Johnny Depp). Lord Cutler Beckett (Tom Hollander) offers Will a deal if he can get Jack’s special compass, however.

And what’s so special about this compass? The story chooses to make us wait for more info about it. In the meantime, Jack has his own problems.

Sparrow once made a deal with spectral pirate Davy Jones (Bill Nighy) and now he needs to pay for it. This ain’t good, so Jack goes to extremes to avoid a confrontation with Jones and his pet beast, the Kraken.

Jack learns of his impending fate from the undead Bootstrap Bill Turner (Stellan Skarsgard), an old pal who also just happens to be Will’s father. Against this backdrop, we find all our old heroes eventually reunited as the tale involves the compass, Davy Jones’s titular chest, and all sorts of action.

My synopsis simplifies matters and probably makes Chest sound more straightforward than it is. In actuality, it provides an awfully convoluted story.

The plot feels fairly simple at its base, but the movie makes matters unnecessarily complicated. It takes halfway through to start to make any sense, as it just keeps us confused most of the time until then.

Despite the movie’s convoluted plot, it manages to deliver the expected goods. The movie runs two and a half hours but it keeps us involved and entertained for much of that span.

Once again, much of the credit goes to Depp. He pulled off the best moments of the original, and he continues to amuse here.

Depp pulls off the very cartoony side of Captain Jack with aplomb but he never feels like he’s slumming. Depp’s performance doesn’t come as a surprise here like it did three years earlier, but he continues to delight.

Chest knows where to find its bread and butter, so it focuses on Captain Jack even more heavily this time. That causes minor problems in story and balance, as the other leads often feel lost in the shuffle. That said, the Captain Jack character never overstays his welcome, so we don’t really mind his dominance.

In addition to the messy story and loose storytelling, I suppose the biggest flaw that comes with Chest stems from the success of the first flick. That one came as such a happy surprise that it burdened the sequel with enormous expectations.

Chest just can’t seem as fresh and original, so it loses that out-of-left-field factor. Who knows – if this one came first, I might be criticizing Black Pearl in the same vein. I think that one’s probably the tighter, better balanced story, but nonetheless, I can see that some of my complaints with Chest stem from factors beyond its control.

I do think Chest worries too much about spectacle and too little on story. A lot of the sequences seem to exist mostly to dazzle us with spiffy effects and action.

These often succeed, but afterward you wonder what purpose they really served. There’s a real Looney Tunes feel to the flick that stretches credulity a little too far on occasion.

Ultimately, Dead Man’s Chest offers enough fun and adventure to compensate for its flaws. The movie plays better during a second screening since one can better anticipate the story problems and focus on the entertainment. This is good summertime popcorn filmmaking.

Footnote: be sure to stick around through the conclusion of the end credits for an interesting coda.

Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Man’s Chest appears in an aspect ratio of approximately 2.35:1 on this Blu-ray Disc. A fairly early Blu-ray, the image seemed watchable but erratic.

During brightly lit shots, sharpness appeared accurate and well-defined. However, in darker scenes – of which we found oodles – the film could seem a little on the tentative side. Overall delineation was still more than adequate but those somewhat fuzzy darker elements could be a mild concern.

No issues with jagged edges or shimmering materialized, and edge haloes weren’t an issuel. Happily, print flaws appeared totally absent, as I noticed no specks, grit or other defects.

Colors heavily leaned toward teal and orange, with an emphasis on blue-green. These tones became almost comical in their intensity, but the Blu-ray reproduced them as intended.

Blacks were generally deep and dense, though they could seem slightly inky at times. Shadows also worked fairly well despite the occasional soft spot. This was a good image for its era but a new encode would likely improve it.

No complaints accompanied the excellent Uncompressed 5.1 soundtrack of Chest, as the soundfield was wonderfully dynamic and involving. The various channels presented a surfeit of information that blended together with great clarity and smoothness.

All elements seemed placed accurately within the environment, and these components moved neatly across and between the speakers. This helped create a good sense of place and made the action all the more engrossing.

Lots of action sequences brought out the strengths in the soundfield. The Kraken attacks added the best moments, but plenty of other elements stood out as strong. These used the surrounds well and created a lively, immersive piece.

I also found the audio quality to live up to high standards. Speech came across as firm and natural, and I noticed no edginess. Some lines became tough to understand, but that resulted from “pirate diction”, not due to poor recording.

Music occasionally risked getting submerged beneath all the action, but the score remained bright and dynamic nonetheless, as the mix depicted these components vividly. Of course, the effects remained the stars of the show, and they appeared well displayed. The different elements sounded distinctive and clean, with no distortion or other issues.

Dynamic range was excellent, and low-end seemed superb. Bass response always stayed tight and rich. Overall, I felt quite pleased with the audio.

How did the Blu-ray compare to the original DVD? The lossless audio showed greater range and impacted than the lossy Dolby 5.1 of the DVD.

As for visuals, the Blu-ray offered superior colors, definition and texture. However, it fails to become the hoped-for upgrade, so it tops the DVD but not as much as one might hope.

Chest presents a good mix of extras on its two discs, and the first includes an audio commentary with screenwriters Ted Elliott & Terry Rossio. Both sit together for a running, screen-specific discussion. They chat about challenges related to the creation of the sequel and matching it with the other flicks in the series, plot and characters, locations and shooting concerns, and other script and production details.

Satisfying but not scintillating, this commentary achieves its basic goals. We get a series of reasonably good notes about the script, and I particularly like the details about cut lines and scenes as well as alterations made by the actors. There’s enough information from the set to give us a decent view of the production as a whole.

That said, I don’t feel this is a particularly full track, and it doesn’t compensate for the absence of a director’s commentary. Perhaps Gore Verbinski was too busy finishing the third Pirates flick to attend. In any case, the writers provide a good but not great chat.

Catty footnote: I must admit that Elliott got on my nerves. For one, he has a really annoying loud, staccato “ha-ha-ha-ha-ha!” laugh that quickly becomes irritating.

In addition, he constantly pronounces “escape” as “ekscape”. I’m sure Elliott’s a great guy, but some of his traits grate on the listener – or me, at least.

Anal Simpsons correction: at one point, the writers cite an episode in which Bart paints eyeballs on his eyelids as an inspiration. This is incorrect; they’re confusing it with a show in which Homer wears glasses with eyes on them to snooze during jury duty.

Exclusive to the Blu-ray, Liar’s Dice offers a gambling game you play against video characters. It uses some film actors in a fun way, which I enjoy, but the game itself seems dull.

Disc One opens with ads for Invincible, The Guardian, The Prestige and Pirates of the Caribbean: At World’s End. No trailer for Chest appears here.

Moving to Disc Two, we open with Charting the Return. The 25-minute, 40-second documentary offers a mix of shots from the set and interviews.

We hear from Rossio, Elliott, director Gore Verbinski, producer Jerry Bruckheimer, 1st AD/associate producer Peter Kohn, conceptual consultant James Byrkit, unit production manager (Caribbean) Doug Merrifield, executive producer Bruce Hendricks, assistant production coordinator Barrett Leigh, special effects tech Frank Iudica Jr., extras casting assistant director (LA) Kristan Berona, and extras casting director (LA) Sande Alessi.

“Return” looks at concepts for the two Pirates sequels and the development of Chest. The show also digs into location scouts and sets, casting and research, budgetary problems, and other issues involved with the flick’s prep.

This show offers a surprisingly blunt look at various aspects of the pre-production. Instead of the usual happy, fluffy tone, this one comes across as cranky. Everything’s a problem, especially since the writers just can’t seem to churn out a script. It’s quite interesting and entertaining.

The disc’s most substantial piece, According to Plan runs one hour, two minutes, 58 seconds. It includes comments from Bruckheimer, Elliott, Rossio, Hendricks, Iudica, Merrifield, Kohn, Verbinski, Rossio, Elliott, camera operator Martin Schaer, script supervisor Sharron Reynolds-Enriquez, production designer Rick Heinrichs, marine coordinator Dan Malone, executive producers Eric McLeod, Chad Oman and Mike Stenson, underwater DP Peter Zuccarini, transportation coordinator Dave Robling, Caribbean unit assistant production coordinator Kelly DeTample, production supervisor Thomas C. Hayslip, stunt coordinator George Marshall Ruge, stunt double Tony Angelotti, DP Dariusz Wolski, gimbal foreman Mark Hawker, shop supervisor Thomas Pahk, 1st AD David H. Venghaus Jr., still photographer Peter Mountain, picture boat coordinator J. Wilfrid White, and actors Johnny Depp, Keira Knightley, Kevin R. McNally, Jack Davenport, Orlando Bloom, Martin Klebba, David Bailie, and Lee Arenberg.

“Plan” picks up where “Return” left off and looks at the actual production. We start with the first day and examine the return to the set from the original flick, filming on the water, and continued script problems. From there we zoom through location logistics and concerns, stunts and action sequences, boats, and various shooting topics.

Though we get a lot of comments from cast and crew, “Plan” mostly resembles a production diary. Shots from the set dominate and give us a solid glimpse of the shoot.

The delightfully cranky tone of “Return” continues, as “Plan” catalogs a mix of problems and obstacles faced by the production. It’s informative and fun in a dark, Schadenfreude way.

An interactive feature called Captain Jack: From Head to Toe digs into many aspects of the popular pirate. You can look at each segment individually – keyed to a pictorial map of Jack – or watch them all at once via the “Play All” option.

If you go that way, you’ll find 27 minutes, 33 seconds of information. Through these we hear from Wolski, Depp, costume designer Penny Rose, property master Kristopher E. Peck, makeup department head Ve Neill, chief hairstylist Martin Samuel,

These segments look at Jack’s costume and look as well as aspects of the character. They focus on the physical elements of hair, makeup, costume, jewelry, props and whatnot, and they become surprisingly detailed.

Actually, I guess that’s not much of a surprise since we take almost half an hour to examine Captain Jack. In any case, we get quite a lot of good information in this solid collection of clips. I definitely appreciate the “Play All” option, as this area would be a chore to navigate otherwise.

Next we find three elements under Mastering the Blade. Each of these featurettes spotlights the sword work of three actors: Orlando Bloom (5:36), Keira Knightley (5:06) and Jack Davenport (5:16).

In addition to those performers, we hear from Bruckheimer, Ruge, Verbinski, Arenberg, and stunt doubles Lisa Hoyle and Thomas Dupont. We see a little of their training and watch the filming of a few specific sword-intensive scenes. These continue the production diary feeling of prior programs and also provide nice details.

Meet Davy Jones: Anatomy of a Legend fills 12 minutes, 32 seconds with remarks from Bruckheimer, Hendricks, Knightley, Verbinski, ILM animation director Hal Hickel, visual effects art director Aaron McBride, digital model supervisors Geoff Campbell and Steve Walton, visual effects supervisor John Knoll, additional visual effects supervisor Bill George, digital artist Mike Sanders, associate animation supervisor Marc Chu, digital production supervisor David Meny, animator Steve Nichols, compositing supervisor Eddie Pasquarello, and actor Bill Nighy.

“Legend” analyzes all the elements that went into the combination of live-action performance and computer work for Davy and his crew. We learn about visual design and a mix of other elements. I love seeing the raw footage of Nighy’s performance, and the show fleshes out the various techniques quite well.

Another featurette appears next. Creating the Kraken goes for nine minutes, 57 seconds, and includes notes from Elliott, Rossio, Arenberg, Bruckheimer, Knightley, Knoll, Verbinski, Nichols, Depp, sequence supervisor Francois Lambert, special effects coordinator Allen Hall, on-set foreman Andrew Weder, and special effects coordinator Michael Lantieri.

We get a few comments about the creature itself before we find details related to the movie’s depiction of it. This follows some practical elements on the set as well as the visual effects techniques used. It adds up to another interesting and useful program.

For a look at the theme park ride, we go to the 13-minute Dead Men Tell New Tales: Re-Imagineering the Attraction. It features details from Bruckheimer, Depp, Walt Disney Imagineering senior creative executive Tom Fitzgerald, senior show producer Kathy Rogers, senior VP creative development Eric Jacobson, director and chief of sculpture Valerie Edwards, sculptor Scott Goddard, animator John Cutry, principal plastics technician Michael Traxler, mechanical lead Rick Taylor, senior concept designer John Gritz, principal show artists Heather Greene and Tod Mathias, and actor Geoffrey Rush.

The show examines changes made to update and refresh the “Pirates” attractions at both Disneyland and DisneyWorld, I don’t know if I like the idea of alterations in such a classic ride; don’t mess with a legend, especially since the introduction of movie characters feels trendy to me.

I do like this featurette, however, as it presents a really nice view of how the Imagineers at Disney work and the challenges they face. We even get to follow Johnny Depp as he experiences the reworked attraction.

A repeat of a feature on prior releases, Fly on the Set: The Bone Cage lasts three minutes, 48 seconds. The featurette presents exactly what one might expect of it: video footage from the set free from interviews, movie clips, or narration.

It’s straight material from the shoot as we watch rehearsals, collaborations and the actual filming. I love this sort of stuff, and “Fly” gives us a fun – albeit brief - look behind the scenes.

Another element with a sibling on the prior packages, Jerry Bruckheimer: A Producer’s Photo Diary runs four minutes, 41 seconds. We see Jerry Bruckheimer’s personal pictures from the set. He discusses his interest in photography and various elements of the production as we watch a montage of his snaps.

Bruckheimer remains one of the dullest commentators ever known, but his photos provide some very good images from the shoot. He’s a talented photographer, so this section presents many fine pictures.

We also find Bloopers of the Caribbean. The three-minute and 50-second compilation offers the standard collection of goofs and giggles. A few amusing moments appear due to a funny screw-up by Jonathan Pryce and some good improvisation from Johnny Depp, but otherwise this is pretty forgettable fare.

The set concludes with the three-minute and 58-second Pirates on Main Street: the Dead Men’s Chest Premiere. We follow Verbinski as he braves the teeny-bopper-lined red carpet at the movie’s Disneyland debut. It’s mildly interesting.

While I don’t think Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Man’s Chest lives up to the fun presented by its predecessor, it holds up acceptably well. The movie packs just enough spry adventure to make it enjoyable and inviting. The Blu-ray offers decent picture along with excellent audio and extras. The movie entertains, but the lackluster picture quality makes this a dated release.

To rate this film, visit the original review of DEAD MAN'S CHEST