Rounders appears in an aspect ratio of approximately 2.35:1 on this single-sided, double-layered DVD; the image has been enhanced for 16X9 televisions. Despite a few flaws, the disc usually presented a positive picture.
For the most part, sharpness looked good. A little softness crept into the image at times, but not frequently. Instead, the movie generally appeared nicely detailed and distinctive. No issues with jagged edges or shimmering occurred, but I noticed mild edge enhancement at times. Most of the DVD’s problems stemmed from source flaws. A mix of specks, marks, and grit crept into the presentation, and I also saw the occasional nick. The movie didn’t look terribly dirty, but it should have been cleaner given its age.
Colors usually were subdued but accurate. The movie went with a dingy golden look much of the time due to all the quiet interiors. The tones consistently seemed accurate and concise. Blacks were deep and firm, while low-light shots came across as appropriately dense but not overly dark. Overall, the image seemed fine other than a few modest problems.
As for the Dolby Digital 5.1 soundtrack of Rounders, it worked fine but never taxed my system. That was fine given the quiet parameters of the film’s action. The soundfield spent most of its time in the forward speakers. The surrounds kicked in with some minor ambience and seemed most active during scenes at casinos. Otherwise, I heard decent stereo imaging for the music in the front, and I also detected adequate environmental material there. The scope always remained modest, though.
Audio quality appeared fine overall. Speech occasionally demonstrated a little edginess, but the lines usually came across as natural and distinctive. Music was consistently bright and rich, with clean highs and firm lows. Effects didn’t play a huge role, but they sounded clear and accurate, with reasonable definition. There wasn’t enough to this mix to merit a grade above a “B-“, but the audio was fine for this sort of movie.
For this new edition of Rounders, we get a mix of extras. We find two separate audio commentaries. The first comes from director John Dahl, screenwriters David Levien and Brian Koppelman, and actor Edward Norton, all of whom sit together for their running, screen-specific discussion. Though it drags at times, the commentary usually comes across as lively and winning. We learn of the project’s roots and development, rewrites and improvisation, casting and character notes, influences and stylistic choices, and a mix of general notes. We also learn a little of the guys’ personal poker experiences. The four men interact nicely and no one participant dominates, though Norton does come across as the “top dog” in a way. Too much dead air pops up, but the track enjoys good energy via the good-natured barbs the guys toss around and it presents a generally positive recap of their experiences with the movie.
In the second commentary, we hear from professional poker players Johnny Chan, Chris Hellmuth, Chris Moneymaker, and Chris “Jesus” Ferguson. All four sit together for their running, screen-specific track. They remark upon the reality of the poker situations in the film as they go into what makes sense and what doesn’t. This means they also reflect on their own patterns and the decisions they would make in various circumstances. They also go into their own experiences in other ways and their reactions to the characters’ decisions.
A fair amount of lingo shows up along the way, which occasionally makes the discussion tough for the layman to understand; the players periodically explain the terms but not frequently enough. Far too much dead air mars the piece as well. Large chunks of movie pass without information, and given the poker experiences of these guys, I can’t imagine that they couldn’t come up with something to talk about during those lulls. Still, this is a fun concept for a commentary, even if it suffers from erratic execution.
A set-top game called “Rounders: Play with the Pros” lets us run through some poker. You first go through a tutorial that lets you build a bankroll, and then you can play. This is fun and entertaining, but the actual game loses some points because it never lets you keep track of your money; when you bet, you don’t know how much you’re wagering and what you have left. You also can’t gauge your opponents, and they’ll bet “all in” repeatedly even when they lose. This makes no sense, so while it’s fun at times, the inconsistent execution causes it to be a bit of a chore.
Next we find a five-minute and 18-second Behind-the-Scenes Special. It presents some movie snippets, a few shots from the set, and notes from Levien, Koppelman, Dahl, Norton, John Malkovich, Matt Damon, Famke Janssen and producer Joel Stillerman. They discuss the inspirations for the film and its locales, poker training for the actors, the flick’s poker realism, the atmosphere on the set and the gambling metaphor. Though short, the special suffers from less of the overt promotional element than usual. It packs some decent information into its brief running time and deserves a viewing.
In the five-minute and 38-second Professional Poker we take a glance at that world. It includes remarks from Damon, Norton, Ferguson, Hellmuth, Moneymaker, Chan, Dahl, professional gambler Bob Stupak, 1976 and 1977 World Series of Poker champion Doyle Brunson, and gaming author/professional gambler David Sklansky. They offer some fairly generic comments about the subject but don’t explore it in any depth. Really, we’ve already heard most of this information elsewhere on the DVD, so this featurette seems largely superfluous.
For more remarks from the four professional players heard in the commentary, we go to Champion Poker Tips. This includes short soundbites from Chan, Ferguson, Hellmuth and Moneymaker. A total of 24 of these appear, and they all last from about five seconds to around 30 seconds. This doesn’t leave much time for insight, so the information tends to be brief and fairly superficial. A few intriguing concepts emerge, but most of them seem pretty obvious. The absence of a “Play All” feature also makes this section a chore to navigate.
The DVD opens with some ads. We get a general preview for Miramax films plus a specific promo for Jersey Girl. These also appear in the Sneak Peeks area with a trailer for The Ladykillers.
Another Tip: If you want to learn more about the game featured in the movie and maybe try it out for free, here’s a great place to start learning. Read everything you need to know about Texas Hold 'Em rules and get tons of strategy tips for your next game.
A guy’s movie, Rounders doesn’t reinvent the wheel, but it presents a consistently intriguing piece. The movie boasts a solid cast and an interesting enough tale to keep the viewer with it. The DVD offers good picture with adequate audio and some generally positive extras. I don’t think either the film or the DVD excel, but both are satisfying enough for me to recommend this release.