Monty Python’s The Meaning of Life appears in an aspect ratio of 1.85:1 on this 4K UHD Disc. Though it showed its roots, the image largely worked well.
For the most part, sharpness appeared satisfactory. A few slightly soft elements appeared at times, but most of the film seemed accurate and well-defined.
No issues with jagged edges or moiré effects appeared, and I saw no edge haloes. Grain felt natural, and no print flaws manifested.
Colors showed nice clarity and vivacity. Though the film often stayed with a somewhat subdued palette, it popped to life at times and demonstrated fairly rich tones, with extra heft from the disc’s HDR.
Blacks seemed deep and dense, while shadows were smooth and clear – within the constraints of the original photography. HDR brought added impact and power to whites and contrast. Though not a visual showpiece, the image satisfied.
On the other hand, the DTS X remix of Meaning of Life disappointed, mainly due to a perplexing soundfield. The reworking of the audio led various sonic components to wind up in places that they didn’t belong.
This didn’t become a persistent concern, as aspects of the track showed up where they should, such as during a warfare scene. That one managed to place elements in logical spots and created a good sense of the material.
Other sequences fared less well, though, especially because dialogue localization felt odd. While lines stayed in the appropriate front center at times, they also often bled to the surrounds in a disconcerting manner.
Other effects also used the back speakers too much, with music as an overly loud factor in those channels at times. Though the soundscape occasionally satisfied, it felt awkward and unnatural too much of the time.
Audio quality seemed erratic as well, with lines that varied from fairly natural to edgy and reedy. The dialogue remained intelligible, at least.
Music and effects also lacked consistency, as they veered from smooth and dimensional to rough and shrill. I got the impression the mix included some re-recorded elements as well, for some of the war-related elements didn’t mesh with the rest of the track. The biggest issue here remained overkill, as the DTS X mix just went too nuts and didn’t support the film well.
How did the 4K UHD compare to the Blu-ray version? The BD’s 5.1 track worked substantially better than this clumsy DTS X mix. It didn’t excel but it matched the film in a superior manner.
On the other hand, the 4K UHD’s visuals seemed better defined, brighter and more dynamic than the grimy Blu-ray. The picture became an obvious upgrade.
With better audio on the Blu-ray and superior visuals on the 4K, what should the viewer do? I’d still opt for the 4K due to the improved picture, but I wish the soundtrack didn’t turn into such a mess.
As we move to extras, we open with an audio commentary from actor/director Terry Jones and actor/animator Terry Gilliam.
Both recorded separate running, screen-specific tracks that got edited into one piece.
The commentary looks at various aspects of the movie’s different sketches. At times, the Terrys offer useful insights about the material and the shoot.
However, more than a little dead air comes along for the ride, and we get a ton of praise for the film and its participants – especially from Gilliam, who often tries to convince us the movie represents peak Python. Gilliam also seems confused about chronology, as he occasionally indicates that he thinks Meaning of Life was shot after 1985’s Brazil.
All of this leads to a highly disappointing commentary. While not devoid of informational value, too much of the track simply feels banal and dull.
An alternate audio option appears via Soundtrack for the Lonely. With it, Michael Palin plays a man who watches the movie.
As he views, the Palin character laughs, hums, farts, and occasionally makes phone calls. Some entertainment results – but not nearly enough to sustain the viewer across the whole film. Though a clever concept, the end result drags.
In addition, the movie can be viewed with a Sing-Along. It simply provides onscreen lyrics during songs and offers nothing more engaging than that.
As we go to video extras, a 30th Anniversary Reunion lasts one hour, 15 seconds. Four Pythons – Michael Palin, Terry Jones, John Cleese and Terry Gilliam – gathered together in London, while Eric Idle joined them via video call from LA.
After a few minutes of general chitchat, they discuss aspects of Meaning of Life as well as the then-current state of comedy and various Python memories. This becomes a good collection of thoughts and a fun way to see the Pythons together.
A 2003 Prologue by Eric Idle goes for one minute, 17 seconds. He presents a comedic poem to introduce the movie and gives us a quick little bit of entertainment.
Titled The Snipped Bits, we get seven cut sequences that fill a total of 18 minutes, 22 seconds. Two – “Martin Luther” and “The Hendys” – come with non-optional commentary from Jones.
“Martin Luther” presents that religious icon as a horny weirdo and proves pretty amusing. Jones regrets its omission and I agree, as it offers the sort of oddball weirdness that Pythons did well.
The rest prove more erratic. “Hendys” just extends an existing scene, and the others feel mediocre.
Jones’ commentary delivers a few notes about the two aforementioned segments. He gives us some minor insights, but the fact we can’t watch the scenes without his chat annoys.
Under The School of Life, we get four elements. The Meaning of Making The Meaning of Life spans 49 minutes, two seconds and involves Palin, Cleese, Jones, Gilliam, Idle, and Python Graham Chapman.
The show looks at the project's origins and development, writing and the pursuit of a narrative theme, Jones as director, aspects of the shoot, and the movie's release/reception. It provides a pretty enjoyable overview of the different topics.
Education Tips runs six minutes and offers a circa 2003 Python sketch that involves Palin and Cleese. Though it doesn’t embarrass, it lacks much real amusement value.
Next comes Un Film de John Cleese, a one-minute, 31-second segment. Also from 2003, it offers a Cleese-centric version of the Meaning of Life trailer. While predictable, it seems mildly entertaining.
Remastering a Masterpiece lasts eight minutes, 21 seconds and offers notes from Jones, Gilliam and film restorationist James C. Katz. It offers a tongue in cheek look at efforts to bring the movie to DVD.
With that we head to Show Biz, a section with three components. Song and Dance occupies 11 minutes, 32 seconds and involves Jones, choreographer Arlene Phillips and dancer Jane Leeves.
This one looks at some of the movie's musical numbers. It turns into an engaging reel.
Songs Unsung brings alternate versions of the movie’s tunes. We get “Every Sperm Is Sacred (Eric Idle Version)” (3:09), “It’s The Meaning of Life (Terry Jones Version)” (2:54) and “Christmas in Heaven (Eric Idle Version)” (3:13). All match 1980s recordings with 2003 lipsynch footage of Idle and Jones to become mildly interesting.
In Selling The Meaning of Life, we get the film’s trailer and two TV spots. “US Promotion” (2:03) shows some dude who impersonated Mr. Creosote – and who did so without a hint of humor.
“Rejects” (0:59) displays nine poster concepts, and “UK Radio” (2:19) presents three English ads. “Telepathy” (2:27) finishes matters with an unusual trailer – one that seems more clever than almost anything in the actual film.
Fish ends the disc with two segments. 2003’s Virtual Reunion (3:09) takes the five surviving Pythons as they get digitally inserted into settings and sort of pretend to interact. It proves moderately amusing.
What Fish Think spans 16 minutes, five seconds and shows aquatic life with occasional “thoughts” voiced as well. It feels more like a glorified screen saver than anything to brings entertainment value.
The set also includes a Blu-ray copy of the film. It presents the same extras as the 4K UHD.
The final Monty Python film, The Meaning of Life becomes a tremendous disappointment. Little of the usual Python wit and cleverness appears in this largely flat and uninspired collection of sketches. The 4K UHD comes with erratic audio, good visuals and a sizable set of supplements. Little of the anticipated Python genius appears here.
To rate this film, visit the Blu-Ray review of THE MEANING OF LIFE