DVD Movie Guide @ dvdmg.com
Review Archive:  # | A-C | D-F | G-I | J-L | M-O | P-R | S-U | V-Z | Viewer Ratings | Main


Hamilton Luske, Ben Sharpsteen
Mel Blanc, Don Brodie, Walter Catlett, Marion Darlington, Frankie Darro, Cliff Edwards, Dickie Jones
Writing Credits:
Carlo Collodi (story), Ted Sears (story adaptation), Otto Englander (story adaptation), Webb Smith (story adaptation), William Cottrell (story adaptation), Joseph Sabo (story adaptation), Erdman Penner (story adaptation), Aurelius Battaglia (story adaptation)

For anyone who has ever wished upon a star.

Celebrate the 70th anniversary of Walt Disney's Pinocchio! The legendary masterpiece that inspired millions to believe in their dreams has reawakened with an all-new, state-of-the-art digital restoration that shines brilliantly on 2-disc DVD. Now, for the first time ever, the richly detailed animation, unforgettable award-winning music When You Wish Upon A Star; and heartwarming adventure-filled story comes to life like never before. Plus, all-new dazzling bonus features transport you into Pinocchio's fantastic world! Join Geppetto's beloved puppet with Jiminy Cricket as his guide on a thrilling quest that tests Pinocchio's bravery, loyalty and honesty, virtues he must learn to become a real boy. The one and only Pinocchio will live on forever in the heart of anyone who has wished upon a star.

Box Office:
$2.6 million.

Rated G

Fullscreen 1.33:1
English Dolby Digital 5.1
French Dolby Digital 5.1
Spanish Dolby Digital 5.1
English Monaural
Supplements Subtitles:

Runtime: 88 min.
Price: $29.99
Release Date: 3/10/2009

Disc One
• Audio Commentary with Film Historians Leonard Maltin and JB Kaufman and Disney Animator/Director Eric Goldberg
• “When You Wish Upon A Star” Music Video
• Disney Song Selection
• “Pinocchio’s Matter of Facts” Subtitle Commentary
• Sneak Peeks
Disc Two
• “Pinocchio Puzzles”
• “No Strings Attached: The Making of Pinocchio” Documentary
• Deleted Scenes
• “The Sweatbox” Featurette
• “Geppettos Then and Now” Featurette
• “Live-Action Reference Footage” Featurette
• Art Galleries
• Trailers
• Deleted Song


Panasonic 50" TH-50PZ77U 1080p Plasma Monitor; Harman/Kardon DPR 2005 7.1 Channel Receiver; Toshiba A-30 HD-DVD/1080p Upconverting DVD Player using HDMI outputs; Michael Green Revolution Cinema 6i Speakers (all five); Kenwood 1050SW 150-watt Subwoofer.


[an error occurred while processing this directive]

Pinocchio: Platinum Edition (70th Anniversary) (1940)

Reviewed by Colin Jacobson (March 16, 2009)

At a point in time when animated feature films are a staple of multiplex screens and even have their own Oscar category, it's hard to imagine that it wasn't always that way. Well, it wasn't, and when Walt initiated the creation of 1937's Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs, he pioneered a new form: the full-length cartoon. Few thought it would work - the film commonly was called "Walt's folly" - but, of course, Disney proved them wrong, as that movie went on to become a huge hit and silenced all nay-sayers.

As such, the reception for Disney's next animated feature, 1940's Pinocchio, was set to be brighter, but it's a mistake to think that the film's success was guaranteed. Snow White easily could have been viewed as a one-time fluke, and the burgeoning field of feature animation could have died a quick death with the failure of Pinocchio.

Although Pinocchio wasn't tremendously successful at the box office during its initial release - it actually lost money, mainly due to the film's then-huge cost of about $2.6 million - its quality further verified the validity of feature animation. Could Disney have withstood a major critical and financial flop with their second release? Maybe, because the short cartoons were still their commercial bread and butter, but it would have been much more difficult.

As it currently stands, Pinocchio eventually turned a profit due to multiple reissues, and it ultimately achieved the standing it currently enjoys as one of the greatest animated films of all time. While I'll quibble with the “classic” title being assigned to some Disney pictures, I have to second that emotion for Pinocchio; it's easily the best of the early features, and it certainly could be argued that it's their best ever.

Pinocchio isn't a perfect film. It runs a little too long, the episodic nature lacks a coherent plot, and it seems somewhat dated at this point in time. However, it's strong enough to easily overcome all of those flaws. The characters are compelling and well-rounded, each episode works nicely and moves along the story, and the film presents an excellent balance of humor, terror, magic and pathos. Really, with the exception of romance, there's pretty much something for everyone in this package.

Three of those four aspects are common to most Disney films, but I have to admit that I think the horror in parts of Pinocchio is remarkably well-portrayed. The menace of Stromboli and the way he states Pinocchio's ultimate fate works well, but the scenes in which the boys are turned into donkeys are truly frightening. The sight of Lampwick's shadow as he mutates into a literal jackass becomes a brilliant method. Since this was animation, they obviously could have depicted the whole thing in front of the camera, but the use of the profile makes the whole thing much scarier; sometimes a hint of terror is more horrifying than blatant symbols.

After nearly 70 years, Pinocchio remains one of the great animated films. I used to only enjoy newer Disney fare, but Pinocchio was one of the movies that convinced me the older classics actually had a lot to offer.

The DVD Grades: Picture A/ Audio B/ Bonus A

Pinocchio appears in an aspect ratio of 1.33:1 on this single-sided, double-layered DVD; due to those dimensions, the image has not been enhanced for 16X9 televisions. Across the board, this was a stellar presentation.

Sharpness consistently looked solid. Only the slightest hint of softness ever occurred, and those instances remained minor. The vast majority of the film boasted fine clarity and definition. I witnessed no signs of shimmering or jaggies, and edge enhancement also seemed to be absent. Expect no source flaws, either. The transfer came totally free from specks, marks or other concerns; it looked remarkably clean.

Colors looked quite bold and bright, with no signs of bleeding or smearing. The film offered a broad palette that always appeared dynamic and concise. Black levels were dark and firm, while shadows seemed smooth and clear. If any problems materialized here, I didn’t notice them; I thought the flick looked fantastic.

In addition to the film’s original monaural mix, Pinocchio came with a remixed Dolby Digital 5.1 “Enhanced Home Theater Mix”. For the most part, the soundfield seemed pretty well anchored in the center channel. The music spread to the sides a bit, and we heard the occasional effect from the right or left.

Nonetheless, it remained essentially a mono mix the majority of the time. The surrounds backed up the music gently and that's about it. Really, this modest agenda was perfectly fine with me, for it didn't overreach the boundaries of what a 69-year-old mono track can produce; it added a bit of ambience to the experience, and that's all it needed to do.

Dialogue appeared a bit tinny but was always clear and intelligible, with a reasonable amount of depth to it. Music seemed clean and smooth, though those elements lacked much bass. Effects were also fairly thin but acceptably realistic and without distortion. A few segments featured more prominent bass, such as during storms. Source noise remained absent. Overall, this was a competent remix but not anything special. Honestly, I’d rather stick with the original monaural track, so I’m glad it’s here.

How did the picture and sound of this 2009 “70th Anniversary Platinum Edition” compare to those of the original 1999 DVD? Both offered improvements. The audio benefited from the inclusion of the original mono mix, though even the DD 5.1 version was a bit better than the 4.0 track on the old disc. That one was a little looser and broader.

Visuals demonstrated the most significant improvements. The new transfer was cleaner, tighter and brighter than its predecessor. I never thought the original disc looked bad, but it was consistently mediocre. The new one seemed vastly superior.

In terms of extras, the 2009 disc blows away the original. The latter included nothing more than a trailer, but the “Platinum Edition” provides a bunch of supplements. On DVD One, we start with an audio commentary from film historians JB Kaufman and Leonard Maltin and Disney animator/director Eric Goldberg. All three sit together for a running, screen-specific chat that also incorporates archival remarks from animators Ward Kimball, Eric Larson, Frank Thomas, Ollie Johnston, Wolfgang Reitherman and Ken Anderson. The track looks at the project’s origins and development, cast and crew, characters and performances, animation and art notes, songs and music, and other production areas.

Though this doesn’t become one of the best historical commentaries I’ve heard, it offers enough useful information to succeed. On the negative side, the three participants devote too much time to general praise for the film; yes, Pinocchio was – and is – a remarkable achievement, but we don’t need to be told that over and over again. Also, I’d like to have heard more of the archival tapes. Commentaries for Snow White and Fantasia consist largely of old remarks from Walt Disney, and it works well; a similar track for Pinocchio would’ve been great.

Nonetheless, I like this commentary and don’t want to sound too down on it. We find a mix of good details that help provide a nice overview for Pinocchio. There’s more than enough solid material here to sustain us.

A text commentary also appears. Pinocchio’s Matter of Facts uses a “Pop-Up Video” format to provide information about the original story and its adaptation for the movie, cast, crew and production elements, characters and music, background details and factoids, and the flick’s release and reception.

Some of the information already appears during the commentary, so don’t expect a ton of new tidbits. What we get seems moderately interesting, though facts can be few and far between at times; they don’t exactly come to us at a rapid pace. This becomes an average compilation at best.

Two components show up under “Music and More”. We find a music video for Meaghan Jette Martin’s version of “When You Wish Upon a Star”. The tune gets a pretty generic dance pop makeover turned even more plastic by Martin’s heavily Autotuned vocals. Indeed, her singing sounds so mechanical that it’s unclear if this occurs to compensate for a lack of talent or if it’s a stylistic choice. I’m guessing the former, as “Star” doesn’t seem like the kind of song meant for android vocals. The video just shows movie clips and general lip-synching from Martin. It’s a dud.

Like many other discs from the Mouse, we findDisney’s Song Selection. This basically acts as an alternate form of chapter menu. It lets you jump to any of the film’s five song performances, and it also allows you to show on-screen lyrics.

DVD One opens with a few ads. We get promos for Blu-Ray Discs, Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs, Up, Disney Movie Rewards and Tinker Bell and the Lost Treasure. These also appear in the Sneak Peeks area along with clips for Tigger & Pooh & Musical Too, Bolt, Schoolhouse Rock: Earth and Disney Parks.

With that we move to all the components on DVD Two. Only one component appears under the “Games & Activities” domain: Pinocchio Puzzles. This offers five virtual jigsaws. The game demands you find the piece that matches specified slots; once you finish each puzzle, you see the corresponding scene from the movie. It’s not especially challenging, but it provides some fun.

Everything else shows up under “Backstage Disney”. The biggest component comes from a 56-minute and one-second documentary called No String Attached: The Making of Pinocchio. In this program, we hear from Maltin, Goldberg, Thomas, Kaufman, Kimball, Johnston, Larson, producer Don Hahn, animators Andreas Deja and Joe Grant, animation historians Michael Barrier, John Culhane and Jerry Beck, Disney historian Brian Sibley, UC Berkeley film historian Russell Merritt, visual development artist Mike Gabriel, author/Professor of Media Studies Thomas Andrae, Case Western Reserve University music professor Daniel Goldmark, special projects creative director Dave Bossert, and actor Dick Jones. We look at the source material and its adaptation, story and themes, character and visual design, the film’s crew and their work, cast and vocal performances, technical elements, sound design and music, and the film’s reception.

Like most Disney projects, this one comes with a heavy helping of praise for the film involved. However, these plaudits seem appropriate, and “Strings” throws in more than enough useful details to overcome the fluffy elements. We get good notes about various aspects of the flick and learn a lot along the way in this informative piece.

Three Deleted Scenes last a total of 10 minutes, 32 seconds. (That includes a 59-second introduction.) We discover “The Story of the Grandfather Tree” (3:19), “In the Belly of the Whale” (4:16) and “Alternate Ending” (1:57). None of these provide final – or even rough – animation; instead, we find storyboards and concept art embellished with audio.

In “Tree”, Geppetto tells Pinocchio about his “ancestry”; it’s cute but would’ve slowed the story to a crawl. “Whale” dwells on Geppetto’s deteriorating state while trapped in Monstro. It’s pretty dark – especially when Figaro tries to eat Cleo and Geppetto almost follows suit – but it seems unnecessary in the greater scheme of things, as we already know that life inside the whale isn’t much fun. Finally, the “Alternate Ending” reflects a mild switch from the movie’s final conclusion, as it reverses the identity of the character who “dies”. The actual ending seems more satisfying

We also receive a Deleted Song. “Honest John” goes for two minutes, 37 seconds as it provides a jazzy number about its title character. It’s unclear where – or if - this would’ve been used in the final flick, but the tune did get commercial release, at least as sheet music. The performance here comes from a rough period recording; it sounds like an acetate, not a released record, but I could be wrong. It’s a fun piece of archival material.

A few featurettes follow. The Sweatbox goes for six minutes, 24 seconds and features Kaufman, Goldberg, Maltin, Beck, Gabriel, Goldmark, and storyboard artist Floyd Norman. “The Sweatbox” refers to story meeting sessions in which Walt Disney and his workers would review works in progress. The featurette gives us a nice look at this then-innovative – and still used - behind the scenes side of the filmmaking process.

Geppettos Then and Now runs 10 minutes, 56 seconds and provides notes from toy maker Cyril Hobbins, marionette maker Lenka Pavlickova, Toy Museum Munich and Prague curator/owner Ivan Steiger, Disney Toys VP of Technology and Innovation Chris Heatherly, Tomy Company General Manager of Seeds Products Kimitaka Watanabe, Emotiv Systems co-founder/president Tan Le, and Emotiv Systems product engineer Marco Della Torre. The show looks at the past, present and future of puppets and subsequent kinds of toys. Occasionally it degenerates into an ad for Disney toys, but the piece provides a decent overview of the way these products have evolved over the years.

For the final featurette, we get the Live-Action Reference Footage. It runs nine minutes, 55 seconds and presents silent footage of film made to give the animators ideas. A narrator gives us details about what we watch. It’s amazing that this footage still survives, and it’s a lot of fun to see.

Next we find some Art Galleries. These break down into “Visual Development” (134 images), “Gustaf Tenggren Art” (10), “Character Design” (63), “Maquettes and Models” (63), “Backgrounds and Layouts” (45), “Storyboard Art” (144), “Production Pictures” (94) and “Live-Action Reference” (22). Across these, we find thumbnailed stills, though “Maquettes” also includes 15 video “turn-arounds” that show all angles of the sculptures. Expect a treasure trove of great Pinocchio art here.

Under “Publicity”, we get three Trailers. These come for the film’s original 1940 release as well as re-issues in 1984 and 1992. All are fun to see, though it’s too bad we don’t get more re-release ads; it’d be cool to trace the changes in promotional style over the decades.

Pinocchio stands as a terrific achievement in animation and a darned entertaining film as well. If it’s not the greatest animated film of all-time, it’s close. The DVD provides excellent picture quality, good audio, and a long roster of interesting supplements. Pinocchio receives fine treatment here, and this is a must-own DVD, one well worth “double-dipping” if you already have the original 1999 disc.

Viewer Film Ratings: 4 Stars Number of Votes: 21
2 3:
View Averages for all rated titles.

Review Archive:  # | A-C | D-F | G-I | J-L | M-O | P-R | S-U | V-Z | Viewer Ratings | Main