The Robe appears in an aspect ratio of approximately 2.55:1 on this Blu-ray Disc. I found a mix of ups and downs in this transfer.
Actually, the ups dominated, and colors tended to look quite good. A few slightly mushy elements appeared, but those seemed infrequent. Instead, the majority of the tones displayed nice vivacity and verve. Blacks were always dark and tight, and shadows showed pretty good clarity; though a few shots seemed somewhat dense, most low-light elements provided positive visibility.
Jagged edges and shimmering never created problems, and source flaws were quite negligible, especially for such an old movie. I saw a speck or two at most, as the vast majority of the flick looked clean and fresh.
The Robe lost virtually all of its points due to softness. Light edge enhancement showed up during parts of the movie, and many shots suffered from lackluster definition.
Though this was most obvious in wide elements – of which we found many – even two-shots could look tentative. Parts of the flick appeared quite good, and I found a lot to like here. Unfortunately, the issues with sharpness meant that I couldn’t give the transfer a grade above a “B-”; the softness became a real distraction.
The Robe offered a DTS-HD MA 5.1 soundtrack that also seemed erratic, though usually good. For the most part, I found speech to sound clean and acceptably natural. Recordings from the era always betray some thinness, and that affected the lines here.
Speech remained easily intelligible but tended to be somewhat edgy and brittle. The mix used some localized speech that worked reasonably well. Sometimes the placement was a bit off, but the lines usually popped up in the logical spots.
Music spread across the front channels but didn’t demonstrate real stereo imaging – or at least no delineation that I could note. I thought the score opened up across those speakers but I didn’t discern definite localization of the elements; this felt somewhat like “broad mono” in terms of music. The score sounded fairly good, at least; the music lacked great dimensionality but was reasonably clear.
Effects panned between channels, but this was done to a gentle degree. Those elements added a little life to the mix. They didn’t have a ton to do, but they seemed positive given the movie’s age. In terms of quality, they fit in with the other aspects of the track. The effects seemed somewhat tinny and a little rough, but they remained acceptably well-defined. Surrounds tended to reinforce the forward spectrum. Some quality issues left this as an erratic presentation, but it was definitely worth at least a “B”.
How did the Blu-ray compare to the DVD version? Audio showed a bit more warmth, while visuals appeared more accurate and natural. I’m fairly sure the Blu-ray used the same transfer as the DVD, so the improvements stemmed from the superior capabilities of the format, but that was still enough to make the BD the better release.
A strong collection of extras flesh out this disc. First comes an audio commentary with composer David Newman and film historians Jon Burlingame, Julie Kirgo and Nick Redman. All four sit together for this running, screen-specific look at the life and career of composer Alfred Newman, technical elements and the use of Cinemascope, the project’s development, cast and crew, and related topics.
If you want to learn a lot about Alfred Newman, this is the place to go. If you want to learn a lot about the rest of the production, you should temper your expectations. Oh, we do find some good observations such as notes about Richard Burton’s self-loathing and the film’s technical side, but these remain in the minority.
That makes the commentary a bit of a mixed bag. On the positive side, we do get a lot of good info about Newman and the music, and the track remains interesting from start to finish. Nonetheless, I wish the participants balanced the various subjects better.
Kirgo becomes almost the sole source of material about the film, as the others focus heavily on the score and Newman. Again, it’s an enjoyable track, but you shouldn’t expect a ton of facts about the production.
Another alternate audio track appears via The Music of The Robe: Alfred Newman’s Score. Select this option and you’ll get to hear Newman’s score play in 5.1 along with the movie. Movie music fans will be happy with this, especially since the score sounds very good – much better than the way it comes across if you opt for the 5.1 track that goes with film, in fact.
The movie opens with an Introduction by Martin Scorsese. In this one-minute, 20-second clip, the filmmaker tells us how his initial screening of The Robe impacted him and he also lets us know about the film’s restoration. Scorsese offers a decent lead-in to the movie.
The Making of The Robe runs 31 minutes, 23 seconds as it presents remarks from film historian Scott McIsaac, UCLA film professor Jonathan Kuntz, director of photography John Hora, Institute of the American Musical president Miles Kreuger, RKO Story author Rick Jewell, Memo from Darryl F. Zanuck author Rudy Behlmer, 20th Century Fox: A Corporate and Financial History author Aubrey Solomon, screenwriter Philip Dunne’s daughter Jessica, director Henry Koster’s son Robert, and actor Jay Robinson. We learn about the source novel, its adaptation and long development, connections to the Hollywood Blacklist and concerns with the Production Code, cast and crew, the use of Cinemascope, the film’s reception and it sequel.
Concise and informative, “Making” gives us a fine look at the film. It tracks the project in a logical way and includes quite a few good tidbits. I learned a lot about the flick and enjoyed the experience.
Next comes The Cinemascope Story. This 18-minute, 39-second show features Hora, Kuntz, Kreuger, Behlmer, Solomon, Koster, Jewell, and Fox publicist Julian Myers. We learn of various widescreen formats and the development and implementation of Cinemascope. This becomes a strong overview of the subject matter.
From Scripture to Script: The Bible and Hollywood runs 24 minutes, 39 seconds and features McIsaac, Jessica Dunne, Professor of History, Religion and Gender Lisa Bitel, Professor of Theology and Culture Dr. Robert K. Johnston, Professor of Biblical Studies and Director of Peace Studies Dr. Daniel L. Smith-Christopher, and Professor of Classical Art and Archaeology John Pollini.
With “Scripture”, we get thoughts about Biblical films, how they reflect their eras, and aspects of The Robe. The featurette offers a compelling examination of these subjects and works well.
From 1969, we get an audio interview with screenwriter Philip Dunne. This chat goes for 22 minutes, 23 seconds and offers Dunne’s thoughts about his work on the script and other aspects of the film. Dunne seems blunt and informative in this enjoyable piece.
With Bonus View, we find a mix of components. “The Robe Times Two” lets us compare the movie’s Cinemascope and “standard” versions. This picture-in-picture piece uses a square box in the lower right corner of the screen to show a different 1.33:1 version of the film as well as comments from film historians Aubrey Solomon and Rudy Behlmer and director of photography John Hora. They give us background for this “flat” edition of the movie and point out some differences.
The main attraction comes from that unused version of The Robe itself, though. As we learn here, the suits at Fox worried that the brand-new Cinemascope process wouldn’t get adopted as broadly as they’d hoped, so they hedged their bets with a “standard” edition. Rather than go the “pan and scan” route, the 1.33:1 version comes from completely different takes, all of which were composed for that aspect ratio.
This makes the “standard” Robe an interesting curiosity. I do like that the presentation lets us observe specific differences between the two, though I wish the Blu-ray offered the option to let us see the 1.33:1 version in a larger presentation without the interruptions from the commentators. It’d be nice to have it in a more “watchable” way. That minor complaint aside, “Times Two” becomes a cool extra.
“A Seamless Faith: The Real-Life Search foe the Robe” consists of 10 featurettes. These can be viewed as a branching feature during the movie or on their own. We find “Inspiration” (3:22), “The Clothes of Christ” (3:27), “Clothes in Biblical Times” (4:16), “Clothes of a King” (3:15), “A Seamless Garment” (3:46), “The Robe on Page and Screen” (6:10), “The Robe and Politics” (3:28), “The Robe in Our World” (4:56), “The Robe in France and Russia” (3:17) and “History Vs. Drama” (2:07).
Across these clips, we hear from Behlmer, Assistant Professor of Religion Kindalee Pfremmer DeLong, Assistant Professor of Biblical Studies Edward W. Klink III, Professor of Religion Jonathan L. Reed, Professor Emeritus of Religion John P. Crossley, Los Angeles Film Study Center Executive Director Rev. Rebecca Ver Straten-McSparran, classical language specialist Mark Bordelon,
The featurettes examine clothes in Biblical times and aspects of The Robe, especially related to ways it attempts historical accuracy. Plenty of good details emerge in this short but concise programs.
Advertising The Robe boasts a slew of materials. “Vintage Celebrity Introductions” lasts one minute, 35 seconds and gives us promotional comments from Richard Widmark, Dan Dailey, Susan Hayward, Robert Wagner, and Clifton Webb. These are as superficial as can be but kind of fun to see anyway.
“Movietone News” brings us five clips: “Cinemascope Hailed by Public and Press” (1:02), “Broadway Hails The Robe in Cinemascope” (1:37), “The Robe (Christian Herald Award)” (1:41), “Millionth Patron to See The Robe” (0:35) and “Cinemascope and The Robe Win Oscars” (1:08). These newsreels are light on “news” and heavy on promotion, but they’re worth a look. (Note that “Herald” lacks some of the original audio.)
An “Interactive Pressbook” occupies 20 screens and brings the film’s original pressbook to life. What makes it interactive? We can click on all of the pressbook’s text to see the material in a more readable manner. That’s a nice touch that makes this feature more useful.
Various promotional stills come in the next three areas. These break into “Poster Gallery” (5), “Lobby Cards” (7), and “Publicity Stills” (62). All are quite good. I especially like the “instructive” drawing of Cinemascope that makes it look like the format offers triple the width of the standard Academy ratio, which is a rather extreme exaggeration; such an aspect ratio would be about 4:1!
Under “Trailers and TV Spots”, we get two trailers. Why is this area called “Trailers and TV Spots” when it doesn’t include any TV spots?
Thanks largely to a stellar turn from its lead actor, The Robe provides an unusually interesting Biblical epic. Sure, it drags at times and suffers from some of the genre’s usual shortcomings, but Richard Burton provides such a strong performance that the film manages to remain compelling. The Blu-ray offers erratic but usually positive picture and audio as well as a solid collection of bonus materials. This isn’t a great Blu-ray but it usually satisfies.
To rate this film visit original review of THE ROBE